I was born in Poonch (Kashmir) and now I live in Norway. I oppose war and violence and am a firm believer in the peaceful co-existence of all nations and peoples. In my academic work I have tried to espouse the cause of the weak and the oppressed in a world dominated by power politics, misleading propaganda and violations of basic human rights. I also believe that all conscious members of society have a moral duty to stand for and further the cause of peace and human rights throughout the world.
Israel’s consulate in the American Midwest offered Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird an all-expenses-paid trip to Israel weeks before asking her to use the state’s anti-boycott law against Turkey and to denounce the International Criminal Court (ICC), emails obtained by Drop Site News show.
The emails, released under Iowa’s open records law, reveal how Israel uses personal ties with US state officials to push laws that punish boycotts and to rally support against international bodies scrutinising its conduct during the Gaza genocide.
In February 2024, Bird received an invitation to join other state attorneys general on a “study tour to Israel” from 25 May to 2 June that year. It was sent jointly by the Consulate General of Israel to the Midwest, the National Association of Attorneys General and the America-Israel Friendship League (AIFL), a New York-based nonprofit. The offer covered flights, hotels, transport, touring, most meals and insurance. Treg Taylor, then Alaska’s attorney general, went on the trip and declared its value at $7,200. The emails do not show whether Bird accepted, and her 2024 ethics filings do not mention the trip.
“Instructions from Jerusalem”
In April 2024, Israel’s consul general, Yinam Cohen, wrote to Bird’s office with what he called “instructions from Jerusalem”. He asked her to investigate whether Turkey’s trade restrictions on Israel violated the “spirit” of Iowa’s anti-boycott law. Turkey had restricted exports of 54 product categories to Israel that month, pending a ceasefire in Gaza. Israel’s then foreign minister, Israel Katz, responded by saying he would appeal to pro-Israel organisations in the US to curb investment in Turkey.
Iowa is one of more than 30 US states with laws targeting the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement, a Palestinian-led campaign that uses economic pressure to push Israel to comply with international law. The laws were passed after years of Israeli government lobbying. Iowa’s law, passed in 2016 and expanded in 2022, forces public funds to divest from listed foreign companies and bars state bodies from awarding them contracts worth $1,000 or more. Civil liberties groups have condemned such laws as an attack on free speech.
Iowa’s anti-boycott law, like those in other states, is written to penalise companies that boycott Israel, not foreign governments. Cohen nonetheless argued that “an inquiry by the state of Iowa would send a strong message to the Turkish government to reconsider their decision”. The emails do not show whether Bird opened an investigation. Florida has since gone further, blacklisting both the Turkish government and individual Turkish companies under its own anti-boycott law in September 2025.
The following month, Cohen contacted Bird again, this time targeting the ICC. In May 2024, ICC prosecutor Karim Khan applied for arrest warrants for Israeli and Hamas leaders. Cohen urged Bird to “speak out against the prosecutor’s decision”, which he claimed “undermines the basic principles of justice and due process”. Within weeks, Bird had joined 19 other state attorneys general in a letter urging Congress to sanction the court. Drop Site News says the letter echoed many of Cohen’s talking points, including denouncing the ICC’s “equivalence” between Israel and Hamas. Among the other signatories were Taylor and South Carolina’s Alan Wilson, both known to have attended the study tour. The ICC went on to issue arrest warrants for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant in November 2024.
Ben Freeman, director of the Democratizing Foreign Policy programme at the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft, a US think tank, said the requests “would certainly raise” alarm bells under the Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA) if an official complied with them. He added that the offer of a free trip to the same country made those alarm bells “louder”. He also said the emails alone were not definitive.
Israel’s state-level network
Separate hacked emails show the AIFL working closely with Israeli officials on anti-BDS efforts long before it organised the attorneys general tour. The emails were published by Distributed Denial of Secrets (DDoSecrets), a whistleblower site, after being obtained by Handala, a hacking group believed to be linked to the Iranian government, and by a group calling itself Anonymous for Justice.
In 2017, AIFL Vice President Paul Kaplan offered to join the Israeli government’s “efforts to counter the anti-Israel and BDS activities”. He was put in touch with Sima Vaknin-Gil, director general of Israel’s Ministry of Strategic Affairs, which led Israel’s covert campaign against BDS. She told him it was “a whole strategy and two years work plan”.
The AIFL has never registered under FARA, and its executive director has said it is not required to. It received a $150,000 grant from Israel’s Foreign Ministry in December 2025 for its tours for state officials. It also received $33,000 from Concert, a quasi-governmental company set up by the Strategic Affairs ministry. Previously reported emails show the ministry wanted to route money through Concert to US nonprofits to get around FARA.
A 2019 Israeli Justice Ministry strategy memo talks of “leveraging” state-level laws against boycotts. In 2025, Israel’s Foreign Ministry sponsored a conference of US state legislators at which Foreign Minister Gideon Saar promoted anti-boycott laws. It has since grown into the State Legislators Israel Caucus, whose first meeting was hosted at the Israeli embassy in Washington.
The blue wave arrived, crested, and immediately flattened into a ripple.
On November 18, House Democrats nominated Hakeem Jeffries to be the next Speaker by a vote of 251 to 11. No one ran against him. The eleven who voted against him were the only ones brave enough to stand up to the mafia-like threats and pressure that enforce loyalty inside the caucus. The so-called progressive wing, including Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, folded and caved with no binding commitments extracted.
The coronation was conducted in secret ballot. The outcome was preordained. The performance of democracy reduced itself to a closed-door ritual in which the only question was how many would bother to register a symbolic no.
This is what the so-called blue wave actually delivered: the same leadership, the same priorities, the same refusal to name the crime. The wave did not wash anything clean. It washed the same people back into the same rooms.
Jeffries is not a reluctant partner in the Gaza genocide. He is an active supporter.
At an AIPAC conference in 2020 he declared that in Brooklyn they consider Jerusalem the sixth borough of New York City, and that his repeated trips were simply visits to “catch up with my constituents.” The line has been repeated for years. It is not a slip.
It is the operating assumption of the Democratic leadership: the occupation is domestic politics and the West Bank is an extension of the borough. The people being displaced are not treated as constituents of any American politician.
Palestinian Americans in Dearborn and Detroit and across the country, who live the consequences remain a marginalized voice inside the party. Rashida Tlaib and Abdul El-Sayed have named the genocide and the occupation in plain language. They have not been given the room to set policy.
The sixth-borough claim extends Brooklyn into the West Bank while treating the communities that know the occupation firsthand as an inconvenience to be managed. There will now be some fiery speeches from Abdul to look forward to, but his well-spoken words will not translate into substantive change without a movement on the outside demanding it.
While Gaza is reduced to rubble and the ethnic cleansing of the West Bank accelerates under the same military that the United States funds and arms, Jeffries and the party he leads continue to treat the supply of weapons as non-negotiable. The midterm victories changed nothing about that commitment.
The public has noticed the disconnect. Jeffries’ approval ratings are abysmal.
Civiqs polling as of mid-November showed him at 22 percent favorable and 56 percent unfavorable. An Economist/YouGov survey before the midterms put his job approval at 26 percent against 47 percent disapproval—worse than the Republican Speaker he is poised to replace. Recent polls show the unfavorable lead running from the mid-teens to the low twenties.
Majorities of Democratic voters and large shares of the broader electorate say they want someone else leading the party. This is not what people voted for when they rejected the previous configuration. The base is not with the leadership. The leadership is not with the base.
The so-called progressives have made their bargain explicit. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and others have demonstrated that they will use the genocide of Palestinians as a bargaining chip for empty domestic platitudes. Healthcare, student debt, and climate language are offered as reasons to stay inside a party whose foreign policy remains fixed.
The Squad and the DSA-endorsed members who ultimately backed Jeffries have shown that the outer limit of their opposition is a press release and a withheld vote that carries no cost. They will not break the funding. They will not force a vote on the arms. They will not treat the ongoing killing as a reason to leave the room.
Pragmatism has become the doctrine of managed decline: stay inside, extract symbolic concessions, and leave the structure that enables the genocide intact.
The public is not fooled. Large numbers of Americans have already concluded that the role of Israel in U.S. politics has become intolerable. The phrase “United States of Israel” circulates because the material relationship is no longer deniable. The United States supplies the weapons, the diplomatic cover, and the vetoes. The Democratic leadership treats that arrangement as permanent.
Kamala Harris lost the 2024 election in part because of Palestine and the genocide. The author of the Democratic National Committee’s internal 2024 autopsy, Paul Rivera, concluded that the war in Gaza cost Harris votes, particularly in Michigan communities with large Arab American populations such as Dearborn. He found the losses accounted for a meaningful share of the shift toward Trump in the state.
Polls conducted after the election showed that nearly 30 percent of Biden 2020 voters who withheld support from Harris cited ending Israel’s violence in Gaza as a primary reason—outranking the economy, immigration, and healthcare for many of them. The official public autopsy omitted the finding. The private assessment did not.
The party’s loyalty runs deeper than public messaging. Five days before leaving the White House, on January 15, 2025—the day a ceasefire and hostage-release agreement was announced—Joe Biden told Benjamin Netanyahu, in a final phone call whose transcript was obtained by The Jerusalem Post:
“You’ve been through hell. I can’t tell you how much I appreciate you and what you’ve been through. I know we’ve disagreed on occasion but, you know… I still love you, pal. I don’t know how you’ve done it all… Next time I think I have a tough job, I’ll think of you… you’re a good man… I admire you. It took a lot of courage to do what you did.”
The private affection toward this wanted war criminal from Genocide Joe stands in contrast to any public criticism. It reveals the relationship that governs the party’s genocidal policy.
The Democratic Party functions as a party of oligarchy under Israeli and Zionist influence. Major donors such as Miriam Adelson—whose family fortune from Las Vegas Sands has long underwritten hardline support for Israel—illustrate the broader pattern of concentrated wealth shaping foreign policy priorities across the political spectrum. For Democrats the most visible instrument remains AIPAC.
Founded in 1954 as the American Zionist Committee for Public Affairs, it was renamed the American Israel Public Affairs Committee in 1959 to broaden its reach. In October 2026, facing mounting backlash, AIPAC announced it would stop endorsing candidates and making direct PAC contributions. It continues to operate its super PAC, the United Democracy Project, which has already moved tens of millions this cycle. The name on the door changes. The money does not.
There is no organized revolutionary left in the United States capable of challenging the root of the problem. The existing left remains trapped inside the party or adjacent to it, calculating the cost of rupture and concluding that the cost is too high. The result is a politics of permanent deferral.
The two-party system functions as a Western genocidal apparatus precisely because neither party is willing to interrupt the arms pipeline or the diplomatic shield. Democracy, in this configuration, is a failed experiment. It produces the periodic illusion of change while the material support for the killing continues. The coronation of Jeffries is the latest demonstration that the apparatus can absorb a midterm wave without altering its core commitments.
Europe supplies the parallel and the contrast. The European Union maintains partnership agreements and arms relationships with Israel while European governments issue statements of concern. Germany and Italy continue to ship weapons. Germany and Italy have repeatedly blocked efforts at the EU level to suspend the Association Agreement with Israel and end preferential economic partnership, even as Spain, Ireland, and others pushed for consequences.
In the same week as Jeffries’ nomination, Italy’s government gave final approval to legislation that writes the IHRA definition into law, supplying police and university administrations with a ready-made standard for treating political speech about the occupation as antisemitic. The measure sits in tension with Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Fascism and Zionism do not require a formal merger; they require only that each supplies the other with the tools and the silence it needs.
Yet across Europe the people have begun to refuse. Skyrocketing costs of living, energy prices, and inflation—driven by the war economy of Ukraine, the U.S. and Israeli campaigns against Gaza and the West Bank, and the United States of Israel’s illegal war on Iran—are pushing ordinary people into the streets. These material conditions have not yet produced equivalent mass action in the United States, but in Europe they already have.
On November 8 more than 200,000 people marched through Amsterdam under the slogan “No money for genocide.” Organizers including Amnesty International and Oxfam Novib reported the demand for an end to arms sales and trade benefits for Israel. In France, Spain, and Portugal the streets have filled repeatedly against the war economy and the genocide.
Dockworkers in Genoa, Livorno, Trieste, and Gioia Tauro have repeatedly blocked military and dual-use cargo. On October 30 more than twenty-five unions across 113 ports in 22 countries refused to load weapons. Italian grassroots unions and student networks have organized independently of the confederal unions, treating the war budget and the genocide as a single problem. Their power is measurable in the continuity of the blockades and the refusal to wait for a parliamentary majority that has shown it will not break with the policy of complicity.
A European-wide student strike is set for Friday, November 20. In Italy a general strike has been called, with another national mobilization scheduled for December 12. These actions link the daily experience of unaffordable energy, stagnant wages, and collapsing public services to the budgets that fund weapons for Israel and rearmament for NATO.
In the United States the “No Kings” protests drew large turnouts in cities and towns across the country, yet the movement that continues to organize has largely retreated into progressive bubbles such as New York City. The slogan remained broad and the demand stayed symbolic. In Italy the parallel call has been sharpened into “No Kings and Their Wars,” an explicit rejection of both monarchical pretensions and the wars those pretensions underwrite. The difference is substantive. One names the palace. The other names the palace and the cargo leaving the ports.
The Democratic Party is a pathetic joke because it has accepted the role of managing a genocidal apparatus while selling the public the language of change. The people who have begun to stop the cargo have already moved past that joke.
The question is no longer whether the blue wave was real. The question is how long the apparatus can continue to treat the killing as a domestic political detail while the people who load the ships, occupy the schools, and fill the squares decide that it is not.
The mechanics of the arrangement are not obscure. Every major arms package for Israel moves through the same committees, the same appropriations process, and the same bipartisan consensus that treats the relationship as permanent infrastructure rather than a policy choice.
When progressive members threaten to withhold a vote on a continuing resolution or a debt-ceiling deal, the leadership calculates the domestic cost and then routes the weapons through other vehicles. The result is that the killing continues on schedule while the domestic program is renegotiated at the margins.
This is not accidental. It is the structure that allows a party to campaign on healthcare and climate while the same party’s leadership treats the arms pipeline as non-negotiable. The blue wave did not disrupt that structure. It ratified it under new management.
The absence of an organized revolutionary left is not a temporary lag. It is the condition that makes the structure durable. Decades of institutional capture, donor dependence, and the calculated fear of rupture have produced a left that can name the problem in statements and then return to the same rooms to negotiate the next continuing resolution.
The calculation is always the same: the cost of leaving is higher than the cost of staying. The cost of staying is measured in the continued transfer of weapons, the continued vetoes, and the continued refusal to confront or indict the crime and the criminals.
The people who have already begun to interrupt the cargo at the docks have made a different calculation. They have concluded that the cost of remaining inside the existing political class is the continued material support for the killing. That conclusion has not yet been reached by any significant organized force inside the United States. Until it is, the blue wave will continue to function as a coronation rather than a breaking point that could lead to real transformative change.
“There is no ceasefire in Gaza. People talk about a ceasefire but at best it’s a reduced fire,” Chris Sidoti said in the latest episode of the Expert Witness Podcast. “The killing continues on a daily basis, including the killing of children.”
“The circumstances that gave rise to our finding of genocide are still operative inside Gaza. And until those circumstances change fundamentally, then the genocidal activities of the Israeli authorities will continue,” the lawyer and expert on international human rights law said.
Sidoti is a former Australian human rights commissioner who also served on the UN fact-finding mission on Myanmar.
His remarks follow two major reports by the UN’s Palestine commission this year, including a report in June concluding that Israel had deliberately targeted children in Gaza, committing genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes in the coastal enclave, as well as further war crimes in the West Bank.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
Both reports built on the commission’s finding in September 2025 that Israel was responsible for genocide in Gaza.
“Our legal judgments now, on the basis of 18 reports produced over five years, is that the Israeli authorities, civil and military, are responsible for the commission of war crimes, crimes against humanity and in Gaza the crime of genocide,” Sidoti said.
‘No doubt the child was deliberately targeted’
Sidoti said many of the cases the commission examined left no doubt that children had been singled out.
Boys aged 11 to 14 were especially likely to be targeted. The Australian cited the killing of two brothers, aged nine and 10, in November 2025.
A drone strike near Bani Suheila killed them while they were gathering firewood for their father, who uses a wheelchair. Israel said the boys were suspects crossing the “yellow line”.
Gaza family mourns boys killed by Israel along Yellow Line
The commission rejected that claim, finding the boys were more than 300 metres from soldiers, were visibly children and could be seen clearly by the drone operator.
“Drones have the capacity to identify the targets,” Sidoti said. “A decision is made by a human being, a controller somewhere, to fire. And so in this circumstance, and in many others that we examined, there could be no doubt that the child was deliberately targeted.”
“Maybe not to tell whether an adult is 25 or 30, but it’s possible to tell that a nine-year-old and a 10-year-old are children, and yet these children were killed,” he said.
The June report said that at least 20,179 children had been killed and 44,143 wounded in Gaza between 7 October 2023 and 7 October 2025.
Children made up 30 percent of those killed and 26 percent of those injured.
Seventeen medical workers described children arriving with single gunshot wounds to the head and upper body, which they attributed to snipers and quadcopters.
‘Imperial stormtroopers’
Asked whether the commission had found evidence for Israeli claims that the children targeted had been engaged in violence, Sidoti said: “No, is the simple answer.”
“Many of them are very young children. I mean, a one-year-old child is not a terrorist. A two-year-old child is not a terrorist. And yet these kids are being killed.”
In the West Bank, he said, Israeli soldiers operating from armoured personnel carriers and tanks “move through the West Bank like imperial stormtroopers from Star Wars”.
“Do they honestly believe that 12-year-old stone throwers pose a threat to an Israeli soldier so heavily armed and heavily armoured? There has not been one Israeli soldier, not one, killed by a stone thrower in the West Bank.”
‘I mean, a one-year-old child is not a terrorist. A two-year-old child is not a terrorist. And yet these kids are being killed’
– Chris Sidoti
Sidoti described the case of a 14-year-old boy who was shot outside his home and left bleeding on the ground for 45 minutes.
Soldiers fired at his mother when she tried to reach him and prevented an ambulance from approaching. The commission traced the shooting to al-Faraa camp in Tubas in November 2025. The boy died, and his body was withheld.
“About the only attention they paid to him during that time was that at one point a soldier dropped a stone next to the boy and then others took photos,” Sidoti said. “Clearly an attempt to frame the boy as a stone thrower.”
The lawyer also described settlers dragging two young children from the yard of their home, holding knives to their throats and tying them to a tree. The commission recorded that in April 2025, two settlers abducted two siblings under five at knifepoint and tied them to a tree in an olive grove.
“The Israeli military knew about it and has done nothing about it,” he said.
‘Highest rate of child amputations’
Sidoti said all four of the genocidal acts the commission identified in Gaza applied to children there: killing, serious bodily and mental harm, conditions of life designed to destroy the group, and measures affecting births.
Israel is carrying out ‘reproductive genocide’ against Palestinians
“After what has happened in Gaza over the last three years, there cannot be a single Gazan child who has not suffered and continues to suffer severe mental and physical harm,” he said. “I just cannot conceive of any child coming through this without having been harmed.
“Gaza has the highest rate of child amputation anywhere on the planet at the moment.”
The commission found in June that Israeli forces directly hit 459 of Gaza’s 564 school buildings, and more than 668,000 school-age children lost access to formal education.
The number of neonatal incubators fell from 178 to 54 by November 2024. By March 2026, 70 percent of newborns were classified as premature or underweight.
More than 1,655 children had been detained in the West Bank since October 2023. A 17-year-old died in Megiddo Prison in March 2025 from prolonged malnutrition, even though the authorities knew about his condition.
‘Not a peace plan’
Sidoti said aid entering Gaza remained below the level agreed under US President Donald Trump’s 20-point plan and below pre-war levels.
“It was simply a vehicle to achieve a reduction in the killing and some easing of the conditions for the people of Gaza. But it’s not a peace plan. It’s not a solution. It is not being implemented even as intended,” he said.
The October report found that since the ceasefire, Israeli attacks had killed more than 1,431 people, including at least 300 children, and wounded 5,026.
‘The Israeli government’s comments are totally irrelevant. People are interested in facts, they’re interested in law, they’re not interested in propaganda’
– Chris Sidoti
At least 196 Palestinians were killed near the “yellow line” between 10 October 2025 and early April 2026.
Furthermore, Israeli-controlled territory expanded from 53 percent of Gaza to at least 60 percent, and the line had become a de facto border, said Sidoti.
UN agencies have recorded continuing deaths since then. Unicef said on 20 October that 351 children had been reported killed since the ceasefire was announced. Among them was 14-year-old Mohamed, killed by an armed drone strike in Deir al-Balah as he walked home from a Unicef-supported learning centre.
The agency said 800,000 children remain displaced and an estimated 60,000 have lost one or both parents.
In July, the UN human rights office said that nine months after the ceasefire was announced, “still, nowhere is safe for Palestinians in Gaza”.
On 5 November, a 12-year-old boy was killed by Israeli gunfire east of Bureij refugee camp, according to Gaza’s civil defence agency.
‘States do not have to wait’
Sidoti criticised governments, including the UK, that decline to call events in Gaza a genocide until the International Court of Justice (ICJ) rules, while having declared genocides in Darfur, Sudan, and against the Rohingya in Myanmar.
“The inconsistency is frustrating and it discredits the states, particularly in the eyes of victims of grave human rights violations,” he said. “States do not have to wait for a court to make their own decision about whether genocide has occurred.”
He said the obligation to prevent genocide should have been triggered for all states when the ICJ imposed provisional measures in South Africa’s case against Israel in January 2024. “And yet it’s as though the court had said nothing.”
The Rohingya case that could redefine the law on genocide
The ICJ will deliver its judgment in the Gambia v Myanmar genocide case on 19 November.
Sidotti said the Myanmar ruling could indicate how much weight the court gives to UN human rights reports. That question bears directly on the Gaza case.
The expert said that Israel has refused to cooperate with the commission since it was created in 2021, accusing it of antisemitism and of being “Hamas proxies”.
Israel did not respond to the commission’s information requests and denied it entry, which according to Sidoti has negatively affected the commission’s ability to investigate crimes against Israelis, not just Palestinians.
“The Israeli government’s comments are totally irrelevant,” Sidoti said. “People are interested in facts, they’re interested in law, they’re not interested in propaganda.”
Published date: 13 November 2026 16:49 GMT | Last update:6 days 1 hour ago
Eisenkot sat in Netanyahu’s war cabinet and promises a ‘Zionist’ government. The parties of Palestinian citizens of Israel have nothing to gain by handing him power
Yousef Jabareen (right), leader of the Joint List, and Ahmad Tibi (centre), head of its parliamentary bloc, sit in the Israeli parliament in Jerusalem on 10 November 2026, the day it was sworn in (Ilia Yefimovich/AFP)
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Gadi Eisenkot, leader of the “opposition” Yashar party, have both been principal perpetrators of Israel’s genocide of Gaza’s Palestinians.
Eisenkot, a former army chief and author of Israel’s genocidal “Dahiya Doctrine” of mass destruction targeting civilians, served in Netanyahu’s emergency “war cabinet” from October 2023 to June 2024.
Both are equally committed to Jewish supremacy in Israel and the 1967 occupied territories and to excluding so-called “Arab” parties from any coalition government.
It is therefore unclear why any segment of the Palestinian people, let alone those who are citizens of Israel and who have suffered the longest at the hands of their Zionist conquerors, would express a preference for either of these genocidal choices.
All the political parties representing Palestinian citizens of Israel have nonetheless offered their services to Eisenkot in order to end Netanyahu’s rule.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
In so doing, they end up helping Israel weather an existential crisis, which Eisenkot himself fears will lead to the final collapse of the Jewish settler-colony as it teeters on the brink of a “point of no return” unless he forms a “national emergency” government.
Since the Zionist movement’s inception and the later establishment of Israel, Zionist leaders have sought to divide and conquer the Palestinian people, thereby weakening their resistance to European Jewish settler-colonialism.
Since the Zionist movement’s inception and the later establishment of Israel, Zionist leaders have sought to divide and conquer the Palestinian people
Those Zionists who mistook themselves for Marxists (in fact, they had always been no more than master-race socialists) insisted on separating the Palestinian peasantry from the Palestinian effendis, the landowning class who oppressed them.
The main wing of the Zionist Organization, meanwhile, fomented fissures between Palestinian Christians and Muslims, especially following the British occupation of Palestine, which began in late 1917. Efforts to co-opt the leaders of the Palestinian Druze community followed, aiming to separate them from Palestinian Sunni Muslims.
In the same period, during the 1920s, the Zionists also exploited the jealousies of the Palestinian elite, allying with some Jerusalem families against other Jerusalem families.
They, along with the British and a segment of the Palestinian elite, went as far as creating a collaborator Palestinian militia force known as the “peace bands” that killed Palestinian revolutionaries during the Great Palestinian Uprising of 1936-39.
From Nakba to Oslo
It was after Israel’s establishment that Zionist efforts to further subdivide Palestinians gathered pace. The 1948 expulsion of the Palestinians created four Palestinian communities overnight.
These were the Palestinians whom Israel failed to expel from the territory the Zionists conquered and who remained inside Israel’s makeshift boundaries, and the refugees living in the remaining parts of Palestine and outside Palestine altogether.
The other two were the Palestinians of what became the West Bank and those of what became the Gaza Strip, the former ruled by Jordan and the latter by Egypt.
Inside Israel, the Palestinians were divided into ethno-religious categories formalised by the Jewish supremacist leaders of the country. The Druze became a separate ethnic category and the Bedouin are also treated as a separate population category, while Muslims and Christians have remained unified despite ongoing attempts to this day to separate them.
More subdivisions would follow Israel’s occupation of the West Bank and Gaza in 1967. The newly occupied Palestinians were subjected to the same occupation law, except for those in East Jerusalem, which Israel illegally annexed and whose population was subjected to separate regulations.
No segment of the Palestinian people had before 1988-93 sought to gain its rights from Israel by selling out the rights of the other segments
Despite these subdivisions, the Palestinian resistance movement arose in the 1960s and 1970s, unified in struggle against the Zionist usurpers and sought the liberation of all of Palestine’s people and land from European settler-colonialism.
This consensus did not last, however, as the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) began to waver on the indivisibility of the Palestinian people and territory. In the mid-1970s, it began to speak of liberating the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem Palestinians as a first phase before the liberation of all Palestinians.
This prioritisation of the 1967 occupied territories and populations over those in the diaspora or in Israel led to the so-called declaration of independence that the PLO announced in Algiers in 1988, which, with its accompanying political programme, only encompassed the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
This was consecrated later in the 1993 Oslo Accords, where Israel agreed merely to negotiate about the status of the 1967 territories and their people.
A whole coterie of West Bank and Gaza elites and intellectuals rushed to separate the interests of the Palestinian people. They acquiesced to Israel’s “right to exist” as a racist Jewish supremacist state in exchange for the independence of the West Bank (and East Jerusalem and Gaza).
In so doing, they forsook the refugees’ right of return and accepted the apartheid structure of Israel and its dozens of racist laws under which Palestinian citizens of Israel languish.
This was unprecedented, as no segment of the Palestinian people had before 1988-93 sought to gain its rights from Israel by selling out the rights of the other segments.
A backfired gamble
Since Oslo, the consensus within the PLO and later the Palestinian Authority (PA), in the Arab world and in the “international” community has been that the one-third of the Palestinians who live in the 1967 occupied territories are the only ones whose rights need to be redressed.
Israel insisted meanwhile that Palestinians and other Arabs must not only recognise its alleged “right to exist”, which no state in the world has, but also recognise its “right to exist as a Jewish state”, something which US presidents from George W Bush to Barack Obama and Donald Trumpinsisted they do.
Why Palestinian electoral gains in Israel cannot alter the racist structure of the state
The gamble of the PLO and PA and their Palestinian elite and intellectual backers has backfired, leading to the ongoing Palestinian genocide in Gaza and the formal collaboration of the PA, as the current version of the 1930s “peace bands”, in repressing the Palestinians.
It has also lost all Palestinians their rights in the discourse of the so-called “two-state solution” regnant in the West and the Arab world.
Israel itself, meanwhile, has begun to come apart. Mizrahi and Ashkenazi populations, religious and secular communities, the Jewish colonial settlers of the 1967 Palestinian territories and the Jewish colonial settlers of the 1948 territories, the right-wing genocidal Jewish supremacists and the left-wing genocidal Jewish supremacists are all at each other’s throats.
The left-wing genocidals understand that there is a need to unify the country’s Jewish citizens through an electoral win. Their strategy, before Israel completely collapses, is the establishment of what former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant called a “Jewish, Zionist, national unity government”, one that excludes the Palestinian Arab citizens of the country.
Gallant, it will be recalled, is the major Israeli genocidaire who called Palestinians “human animals” and the only Israeli, alongside Netanyahu, currently wanted for his crimes by the International Criminal Court.
The right-wing genocidals believe they can unify Jewish citizens by smashing the left-wing genocidals through the juridical transformation of the country.
In the Israeli elections of 27 October, the right-wing genocidals won 27 seats for the Likud party, while the left-wing genocidals, represented by Yashar, lost with no more than 21 seats.
The ongoing popular support of Jewish citizens who gave Likud its electoral win is being touted as a Netanyahu loss in the face of the win of other Jewish political parties in the country, let alone of “Arab” parties. This is a most inaccurate representation of the elections.
The majority of Jewish voters voted for the right-wing genocidals, giving the Netanyahu-led coalition 53 seats in the Israeli parliament, while Eisenkot’s “opposition” bloc of left-wing genocidals was only able to garner 48 seats with a minority of Jewish voters. This leaves the Palestinian citizens of Israel, whose parties won a total of 19 seats.
Meagre improvements
The experience of the indigenous Palestinian citizens in Jewish supremacist Israel has been horrific since 1948. They lived under martial law and racist pass laws for almost two decades and still have to submit to dozens of racist laws that privilege Jewish colonists over them.
They are also subjected to the government’s theft of their land, which is transferred to Jewish colonists, to constant police surveillance, to deprivation of social services and control over their underfunded education system, and to all-out repression and the occasional massacres.
These include the Kafr Qasim massacre of 1956, the Land Day massacre of 1976 and the Second Intifada massacre of 2000, to name some of the major atrocities to which they continue to be subjected.
In previous decades, Palestinian citizens’ participation in Israeli elections was celebrated by Zionists in the West to whitewash the Jewish supremacist state’s image as an inclusive “democracy”. The justification that Palestinians gave was the fact that they are taxpayers who are denied resources and government services.
They hoped that representation would push the government to provide more resources, decrease repression, safeguard whatever meagre lands they still own and which escaped Israeli confiscation, and improve their economic lot. After they achieved only meagre improvements over the decades, this rationale no longer holds.
Overall, the dire situation of Palestinian citizens of Israel has deteriorated, despite an increase in the number of middle-class Palestinians and their acquisition of education, partly thanks to funding by the US-based non-governmental organisation the New Israel Fund (NIF).
Established in 1979, NIF is an organisation that insists Israel should remain a “Jewish” state but which hopes to whitewash anti-Palestinian discrimination by reducing the stark differences in every index of life between the privileged Jewish colonists and the indigenous Palestinians. It is mostly funded by non-Israeli Jewish liberals.
Still, discrimination and inequality remain staggering, let alone the differential in rights between Palestinians and the Jewish colonists.
With its refusal to police criminal elements in the Palestinian community, if it has not actually encouraged them, Israel has drowned Palestinian communities in the country in gang-related crimes, not unlike the FBI strategy in African-American communities since the 1960s.
While Knesset representation has alleviated certain budgetary shortfalls for Palestinian citizens in towns and villages in the past, it has not made a dent in Israel’s commitment to Jewish supremacy, legally or institutionally.
Such participation in elections also continues to whitewash Israel’s foundational racism, making many question if it is worthwhile.
Litmus test
The elections are a litmus test for the “Arab” political parties, whose participation can only rescue Israel by supporting an alternative genocidal and colonising government to Netanyahu’s.
This ignores the fact that the situation of the Palestinians in Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem, let alone in the diaspora, will not change one iota, and neither will the situation of the Palestinian citizens of Israel. It is only the Israeli genocidal parties that will benefit.
Indeed, both Netanyahu and Eisenkot have nothing but contempt for Palestinian citizens and their parties and have openly rejected partnering with them in any future government.
Still, all the Arab political parties officially recommended Eisenkot to form a government, which Israeli President Isaac Herzog formally asked him to do on 8 November.
How is backing Eisenkot, an active perpetrator and ongoing supporter of the genocide, a vote against a genocidal government?
Eisenkot’s role in genocide and his Jewish supremacy are not unknown to the Palestinian party leaders. The leader of the National Democratic Assembly, Sami Abu Shehadeh, is clear that his party’s support for Eisenkot does not mean that they have overcome their differences.
“Nobody thinks he is a good candidate. We are in special historical circumstances, and we have a decision in the party, for which the people elected us, namely getting rid of the government of genocide. We do not have easy choices,” he said.
This is an odd explanation. How is backing Eisenkot, an active perpetrator and ongoing supporter of the genocide, a vote against a genocidal government?
As for Yousef Jabareen, the leader of the Joint List, an alliance of several parties led by Palestinian citizens, he has spoken bitterly against the Netanyahu government’s ongoing racist campaign to delegitimise the votes of Palestinian citizens.
He has implored the Eisenkot camp to speak against the racist campaign. Eisenkot, for his part, has insisted that his government would be a “Zionist” government, wherein “Zionist” is a synonym for Jewish supremacist and racist, and more accurately for a government free of Arabs, or in German, “Araberrein”.
He has since appeared to moderate his position, suggesting that he might agree to head a minority government relying on what the AFP news agency called “outside votes from Israeli-Arab parties” while seeking to form a stable government with majority support.
What “outside votes” means is relying on the parliamentary support of “Arab” political parties, which would not officially join his ruling Jewish coalition and would not pollute its Jews-only constituents.
Decisive moment
The Palestinian parties recommended Benny Gantz, a former Israeli general, to be prime minister in 2020, as the departing Palestinian parliamentarian Ayman Odeh has bragged, except that Gantz spurned them and joined a Netanyahu national unity government.
Gantz became defence minister and launched the 2021 attack on Gaza, killing more than 250 Palestinians. When the Palestinian parties recommended Gantz, however, Israel was not imploding as it is now.
Unlike the rest of the Palestinian party leaders, let alone the Palestinian Islamists purged and persecuted by Israel, the Islamist Mansour Abbas, leader of the United Arab List, is the extremist Palestinian normaliser with Israel who constantly concedes Palestinian rights.
On 10 November, Israeli media reported that he was willing to recognise Hamas as a terrorist organisation in exchange for a “real partnership” with Eisenkot’s bloc.
How an election defeat triggered a carnival of racism against Palestinians
Abbas denied the following day having made such a statement. He had, however, told his faction on 10 November that his party had “repeatedly accepted the dismantlement of Hamas” and wanted “to be part of the coalition and the next government”.
The problem all along has been that such Palestinian participation in elections and support for Zionist parties has never succeeded in weakening the racist system under which Palestinians in Israel suffer.
Given this stark fact, what is the horizon of such participation in the minds of these party leaders? What is it that they think they can achieve besides helping Israel stabilise?
If the Palestinian parties succeed in helping Israel avert the ongoing crisis, the rest of the Palestinians will blame them for selling out their rights, not unlike how the majority of Palestinians continue to heap scorn on the collaborator Palestinian Authority.
Palestinian citizens of Israel have endured the longest Zionist and Israeli racist rule and oppression, like their compatriots who were expelled in 1948 and whom successive Israeli governments have never allowed to return.
This is a decisive moment for Palestinian citizens of Israel and their political parties to stand up to their racist oppressors and to refuse to help them stabilise the settler-colony.
With the dismal record of the results of their electoral participation, it is high time that Palestinians in Israel think of political alternatives that would substantively improve their lives rather than ones that maintain their oppression and the oppression of the rest of the Palestinian people.
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Eye.
Joseph Massad is professor of modern Arab politics and intellectual history at Columbia University, New York. He is the author of many books and academic and journalistic articles. His books include Colonial Effects: The Making of National Identity in Jordan; Desiring Arabs; The Persistence of the Palestinian Question: Essays on Zionism and the Palestinians, and most recently Islam in Liberalism. His books and articles have been translated into a dozen languages.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio has once again attacked the global system of laws, norms, and principles instituted to place limits on international armed violence. Advocating for a return to might-makes-right barbarism during a keynote speech on Friday, Rubio threatened to use military force against the International Criminal Court, which prosecutes individuals accused of the gravest atrocities. Warning that if the ICC was “foolish enough to try to enforce their paper decrees on Americans, our answer will probably be the same as the Roman general Pompey when he said to those who were trying to invoke their city’s charters against his legions. … ‘Stop quoting laws to men with swords.’”
Rubio’s effort to undermine the principles and rules that regulate the means and methods of warfare and the humanitarian protection of civilian populations, sick and wounded combatants, and prisoners of war is part of the Trump administration’s wide-ranging effort to upend the rules-based international order that the U.S. has championed — but often failed to abide by — since World War II.
Speaking before the conservative Federalist Society at the National Lawyers Convention in Washington, D.C., Rubio disparaged the ICC as a “fake court” and “an unelected world tribunal, which claims to supersede the laws and constitutions of sovereign states, even those who never signed up for it.”
Rubio’s tirade was the latest salvo in a long-running campaign against the ICC by President Donald Trump’s administration, which has vowed to cripple the court. In October, after former ICC judge Navanethem “Navi” Pillay was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, Trump — who has relentlessly campaigned for the award — was enraged and derided the South African jurist as “a liberal person who works at the United Nations, who nobody has ever heard of.”
Hours after the award was announced, the U.S. imposed sanctions on the ICC. These latest sanctions are intended to turn the judicial organ into an economic pariah. They prohibited the court from conducting dollar-denominated transactions, froze its U.S.-based assets, and barred the judicial body from using the U.S. banking system or working with American institutions — effectively blacklisting the court.
The ICC was created by the international community to investigate and prosecute war crimes, crimes against humanity, genocide, and the crime of aggression — when one country uses armed force against another without legal justification. The Hague, Netherlands-based court is unique as a permanent judicial organ capable of prosecuting anyone, infantry soldiers and sitting heads of state alike, for humanity’s gravest crimes if they are committed in the territories of its 125 member states. The ICC is critically a court of last resort that will only intervene when domestic jurisdictions either fail to hold their own service members and political leaders accountable, or when state parties to the court call for an investigation.
While the Trump administration’s timing in sanctioning the ICC was notable, this latest strike against the court is just one facet of the Trump administration’s yearslong campaign to — in the words of Rubio’s State Department — “dismantle” it. The effort dates back to 2020, when the first Trump administration imposed sanctions on ICC officials after the court opened an investigation into alleged U.S. war crimes and crimes against humanity committed in Afghanistan.
Overturned by the Biden administration in 2021, the first round of U.S. sanctions against the court were replaced last February by a new series targeting the court’s chief prosecutor, its two deputy prosecutors, and six of its judges. All of these judges had either investigated the actions of U.S. nationals in Afghanistan or were part of the ICC’s decision to issue arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant for their co-perpetration of “the war crime of starvation” and crimes against humanity in Gaza.
Though the litany of prior U.S. sanctions against the court impacted the lives of those nine individuals and their families — cutting them off from their bank accounts, emails, and blocking their travel — the actions were piecemeal and did not fully upend the work of the court.
Now, all of the ICC’s U.S.-based partner organizations have six months to completely cut ties with the court or face legal retribution. What’s more, since the current global economic system is built upon the U.S. dollar, international — particularly European — organizations often preemptively abide by U.S. sanctions even if their workings fall completely outside of America’s jurisdiction. For example, when the French company Axa terminated its life and health insurance contracts with the ICC on October 1, the insurer reportedly cited the escalating campaign by the U.S. against the court.
Absent the implementation of effective countermeasures — like amending and enforcing the EU Blocking Statute, which can shield EU individuals and businesses from “unlawful” third-country sanctions — this latest move by the U.S. may not kill the ICC, but it will cut off the judicial organ’s blood supply.
Victors’ Justice?
For over 80 years, the U.S. has enjoyed the privilege of proscribing — and not necessarily abiding by — international law. American representatives served as the chief arbiters of the post-World War II Nuremberg and Tokyo military tribunals that prosecuted Nazi and Japanese war criminals, which are seen by many in the field as the birthplaces of modern international criminal law. American arbiters, notably U.S. Supreme Court Justice Robert H. Jackson, led the victors of the Second World War as they tried and prosecuted their former adversaries for novel notions of wrongdoing, including crimes against peace and crimes against humanity. These newly defined criminal acts form the bedrock of the ICC’s jurisdiction.
At the International Military Tribunal for the Far East, all 25 major Japanese leaders were convicted, with seven receiving death sentences. Judge Radhabinod Pal of India argued for the acquittal of all 25. In his dissent, he complained that the tribunal dispensed victors’ justice. He said that America’s atomic strikes on Hiroshima and Nagasaki were among the most criminal acts of the conflict, yet immune from prosecution.
Indeed, the international criminal justice system was never intended to hold the U.S. or its allies accountable. And in the decades since, consecutive U.S. administrations have wielded the nation’s political and military strength to avoid any semblance of international legal oversight.
Although relations with the court have oscillated over the course of Democratic and Republican administrations, the U.S. has always been wary of the court’s potential jurisdiction over American nationals. From the court’s conception, in which the U.S. played a role, the global hegemon has continuously shown its disdain for the court’s territorial jurisdiction. While the ICC cannot prosecute any American nationals for their actions in the U.S., it does have jurisdiction over acts undertaken, by U.S. nationals or otherwise, within the territories of its member nations including Afghanistan, Libya, and Palestine.
Under the Clinton administration in the 1990s, the U.S. was one of only seven drafting nations to initially veto the Rome Statute — the international treaty that created the ICC — due to its concerns over the court’s territorial jurisdiction. Later, in 2002, the same year the ICC was established, the George W. Bush administration signed the Hague Invasion Act into law. The act, which is still in effect, grants the president the legal backing to use military force against the court in order to free any U.S. or allied person held or imprisoned by the ICC. The Bush administration subsequently pressured dozens of countries to agree to never transfer U.S. nationals to the ICC, and threatened to cut military assistance, cease counterterrorism operations, or cut humanitarian aid if these states did not comply. Though relations with the ICC thawed somewhat under the Obama administration in the 2010s, the U.S. has never shown a substantial interest in joining the court and has worked for years to restrict its jurisdiction.
The Trump administration’s courtwide sanctions on the ICC are, however, a far leap beyond the pressure campaigns against the court and its member states by prior U.S. administrations. While the Trump administration cares little for the thin veneer of justice that prior U.S. administrations sought to maintain, the ongoing campaign to “dismantle” the ICC is just one piece of a larger effort by the current administration to ensure the U.S. military can act with impunity.
Soon after taking office, Trump and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth ordered a mass purge of senior judge advocates general. Among their many functions, JAGs historically educated military leaders on the laws that prohibit the use of the U.S. military in domestic law enforcement and ensured commanders were aptly informed of the international legal obligations to protect civilians and prisoners of war. When asked about the mass layoffs in February 2025, Hegseth explained that the action was taken to remove potential “roadblocks to orders that are given by a commander in chief.”
When taken together, the administration’s cuts to internal legal mechanisms and policy programs intended to maintain law and protect civilians, as well as its ongoing attempts to dismantle the ICC, can be seen as two aspects of a larger campaign to eradicate all avenues of military oversight.
The Fight for Justice Will Continue
The sweeping courtwide sanctions against the ICC are formidable for the same reasons they are survivable: They aim to isolate the court from its broad system of support. The international criminal justice system depends on evidence. This evidence is not found in The Hague; it is brought to it by an array of local, national, and international investigators, researchers, watchdogs, and atrocity survivors.
The evidence needed to confirm the genocide in Palestine; the U.S. bombing of the elementary school in Minab, Iran; and the extrajudicial killings of fisherman in the Caribbean would not exist without the networks of dedicated researchers, local journalists, and courageous survivors. And the work of these people, while critical to the court’s functions, will continue, even if the court is dismantled brick by brick.
The ICC has strongly condemned the U.S. sanctions. ICC President Tomoko Akane has said that the court will “continue to fully discharge its mandate, with independence and impartiality, acting only on the basis of the law and the evidence, for the sake of the countless victims of grave crimes.” Pillay has also used the publicity stemming from her Nobel Peace Prize to showcase the court’s work. She further dedicated her award to “all the survivors of international crimes” as well as the international jurists “whose compassion and courage continue to ensure that impunity will not be allowed to reign.”
In his speech on Friday, Rubio took aim at those very jurists, declaring that the U.S. would never submit to the “sterile vision of radical judges or soulless global bureaucrats.” He claimed that this “global elite” was using international law as “an instrument to advance their interests under the pretense of universal principles.” This was, in fact, a stark about-face for Rubio, who was an advocate for international law during his 14 years as a U.S. senator. He even co-sponsored a resolution encouraging other nations to support the ICC’s investigations of Russian war crimes in Ukraine.
Rubio claimed that those who advocate for the restraint of law over all nations are anti-American. “For these people — the fundamental purpose of the law, American law and international law alike, is to weaken the United States,” he claimed. “It is to hinder the American government’s ability to defend American interests at home and abroad.” He continued, “There is nothing — there is nothing — in our history or the history of any other great nation that requires us to recognize the authority or legitimacy of any of these ridiculous ideas.”
Prior to Rubio’s speech, however, Pillay offered up a differing vision of America. In her estimation, Americans are not the singularly self-interested, lawless, reprobates envisioned by Rubio but a people who eschew limitless violence and value humanitarian principles. “I know,” she said, “that Americans support the principle of ending impunity for these serious crimes and that they support justice and accountability.”
Ashley Gate is a freelance foreign affairs correspondent with Foreign Exchanges and a guest lecturer on international arms control at Columbia University’s Institute for the Study of Human Rights.
The head of the Israeli spy agency Mossad, Roman Gofman, lobbied for the resumption of the US-Israeli bombing campaign against Iran during his visit to Washington last week, Reuters reported on Wednesday.
The report, which cited two unnamed sources briefed on the visit, said that Gofman met with senior US officials, including CIA Director John Ratcliffe, and also traveled to Florida for talks with Steve Witkoff, who has previously led US negotiations with Iran.
While the US has been launching strikes against Iran and escalating the economic sanctions and blockade, President Trump so far has held off on escalating to a full-scale bombing campaign, something Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is likely desperate for, as he is now leading a caretaker government and may lose power after Gadi Eisenkot was tasked with forming an Israeli government.
US Air Force F-15s and Israeli Air Force F-35s fly in formation as part of a bilateral exercise in the US Central Command area of responsibility, November 29, 2022. (US Air Force photo)
Gofman’s trip to the US coincided with a visit from Ron Dermer, Israel’s former strategic affairs minister and a close ally of Netanyahu. Dermer was also meeting with Trump administration officials and pushing for joint US-Israeli strikes on Iran, and the sources speaking to Reuters said both visits were part of Netanyahu’s effort to re-escalate the war. The report said that Gofman passed “intelligence” to US officials about Iran’s nuclear program.
A White House official told Reuters that Trump believes the economic campaign was “devastating” to Iran, so there was no need for “major combat operations.” But the war continues to escalate as the US and Iran have been trading strikes, and Iranian forces continue daily attacks on commercial shipping in the Strait of Hormuz.