Nasir Khan, January 23, 2014
[The following remarks are part of the discussion that started on
Facebook with a quotation of English philosopher, Bertrand Russell.]
First of all, there are many people who believe god, devil, angels,
etc., are not mere fantastic ideas but they really exist. One proof:
they are mentioned in some holy books. And in some holy books god is
reported to have spoken to his selected few. The holy books that are
revealed are from god; therefore they represent the obvious truth which
no one can or should find fault with. In fact, the believers in god have
internalised such a mode of thinking that any critical look at it is
regarded as wrong and a result of mental confusion. At the same time,
the term ‘god’ means different things to different people. But the idea
of god entails some sort of belief in a ‘supernatural being’ or ‘power’.
In monotheistic religions, starting with Judaism, many deities were
finally reduced to only one god (this is despite Akhenaton’s early
attempt to introduce Aton as the sole god but the project collapsed
after his death).
Secondly, the believers in god have offered some well-known arguments
in support of the existence of god. At present, I’ll only briefly
mention their names: the ontological argument, the causal argument, the
argument from contingency, the teleological argument or argument by
design, the argument from religious experience, the argument from
miracles and the utility argument. These arguments have been subjected
to a closer look by philosophers. None of these has stood the test of
analytical scrutiny. All of them have been refuted and put aside.