Friday, June 27, 2008

The Big Outcome of the '60s: The Triumph of Capitalism

By Slavoj Zizek, In These Times. Posted June 27, 2008.


After the social tumult of the '60s capitalism usurped resistance itself, turning attempts at subversion into commodities.

In 1968 Paris, one of the best-known graffiti messages on the city's walls was "Structures do not walk on the streets!" In other words, the massive student and workers demonstrations of '68 could not be explained in the terms of structuralism, as determined by the structural changes in society, as in Saussurean structuralism. French psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan's response was that this, precisely, is what happened in '68: structures did descend onto the streets. The visible explosive events on the streets were, ultimately, the result of a structural imbalance.

There are good reasons for Lacan's skeptical view. As French scholars Luc Boltanski and Eve Chiapello noted in 1999's The New Spirit of Capitalism, from the '70s onward, a new form of capitalism emerged.

Capitalism abandoned the hierarchical Fordist structure of the production process -- which, named after auto maker Henry Ford, enforced a hierarchical and centralized chain of command -- and developed a network-based form of organization that accounted for employee initiative and autonomy in the workplace. As a result, we get networks with a multitude of participants, organizing work in teams or by projects, intent on customer satisfaction and public welfare, or worrying about ecology.

In this way, capitalism usurped the left's rhetoric of worker self-management, turning it from an anti-capitalist slogan to a capitalist one. It was Socialism that was conservative, hierarchic and administrative.

The anti-capitalist protests of the '60s supplemented the traditional critique of socioeconomic exploitation with a new cultural critique: alienation of everyday life, commodification of consumption, inauthenticity of a mass society in which we "wear masks" and suffer sexual and other oppressions.

The new capitalism triumphantly appropriated this anti-hierarchical rhetoric of '68, presenting itself as a successful libertarian revolt against the oppressive social organizations of corporate capitalism and "really existing" socialism. This new libertarian spirit is epitomized by dressed-down "cool" capitalists such as Microsoft's Bill Gates and the founders of Ben & Jerry's ice cream.

What survived of the sexual liberation of the '60s was the tolerant hedonism readily incorporated into our hegemonic ideology. Today, sexual enjoyment is not only permitted, it is ordained -- individuals feel guilty if they are not able to enjoy it. The drive to radical forms of enjoyment (through sexual experiments and drugs or other trance-inducing means) arose at a precise political moment: when "the spirit of '68" had exhausted its political potential.

At this critical point in the mid-'70s, we witnessed a direct, brutal push-toward-the-Real, which assumed three main forms: first, the search for extreme forms of sexual enjoyment; second, the turn toward the Real of an inner experience (Oriental mysticism); and, finally, the rise of leftist political terrorism (Red Army Faction in Germany, Red Brigades in Italy, etc.).

Continued . . .

The Nuclear Expert Who Never Was

AP photo / Henry Arvidsson / United Nations

An Iraqi Scud missile awaits destruction by United Nations weapons inspectors in Iraq in this undated file photo.

By Scott Ritter | Truthdig, June 26, 2008

I am a former U.N. weapons inspector. I started my work with the United Nations in September 1991, and between that date and my resignation in August 1998, I participated in over 30 inspections, 14 as chief inspector. The United Nations Special Commission, or UNSCOM, was the organization mandated by the Security Council with the implementation of its resolutions requiring Iraq to be disarmed of its weapons-of-mass-destruction capabilities. While UNSCOM oversaw the areas of chemical and biological weapons, and ballistic missiles, it shared the nuclear file with the International Atomic Energy Agency, or IAEA. As such, UNSCOM, through a small cell of nuclear experts on loan from the various national weapons laboratories, would coordinate with the nuclear safeguards inspectors from the IAEA, organized into an “Action Team” dedicated to the Iraq nuclear disarmament problem. UNSCOM maintained political control of the process, insofar as its executive chairman was the only one authorized to approve a given inspection mission. At first, the IAEA and UNSCOM shared the technical oversight of the inspection process, but soon this was transferred completely to the IAEA’s Action Team, and UNSCOM’s nuclear staff assumed more of an advisory and liaison function.

In August 1992 I began cooperating closely with IAEA’s Action Team, traveling to Vienna, where the IAEA maintained its headquarters. The IAEA had in its possession a huge cache of documents seized from Iraq during a series of inspections in the summer of 1991 and, together with other U.N. inspectors, I was able to gain access to these documents for the purpose of extracting any information which might relate to UNSCOM’s non-nuclear mission. These documents proved to be very valuable in that regard, and a strong working relationship was developed. Over the coming years I frequently traveled to Vienna, where I came to know the members of the IAEA Action Team as friends and dedicated professionals. Whether poring over documents, examining bits and pieces of equipment (the IAEA kept a sample of an Iraqi nuclear centrifuge in its office) or ruminating about the difficult political situation that was Iraq over wine and cheese on a Friday afternoon, I became familiar with the core team of experts who composed the IAEA Action Team.

I bring up this history because during the entire time of my intense, somewhat intimate cooperation with the IAEA Action Team, one name that never entered into the mix was David Albright. Albright is the president of the Institute for Science and International Security (ISIS, an institute which he himself founded), and has for some time now dominated the news as the “go-to” guy for the U.S. mainstream media when they need “expert opinion” on news pertaining to nuclear issues. Most recently, Albright could be seen commenting on a report he authored, released by ISIS on June 16, in which he discusses the alleged existence of a computer owned by Swiss-based businessmen who were involved in the A.Q. Khan nuclear black market ring. According to Albright, this computer contained sensitive design drawings of a small, sophisticated nuclear warhead which, he speculates, could fit on a missile delivery system such as that possessed by Iran.

I have no objection to an academically based think tank capable of producing sound analysis about the myriad nuclear-based threats the world faces today. But David Albright has a track record of making half-baked analyses derived from questionable sources seem mainstream. He breathes false legitimacy into these factually challenged stories by cloaking himself in a résumé which is disingenuous in the extreme. Eventually, one must begin to question the motives of Albright and ISIS. No self-respecting think tank would allow itself to be used in such an egregious manner. The fact that ISIS is a creation of Albright himself, and as such operates as a mirror image of its founder and president, only underscores the concerns raised when an individual lacking in any demonstrable foundation of expertise has installed himself into the mainstream media in a manner that corrupts the public discourse and debate by propagating factually incorrect, illogical and misleading information.

In his résumé Albright prominently advertises himself as a “former U.N. weapons inspector.” Indeed, this is the first thing that is mentioned when he describes himself to the public. Witness an Op-Ed piece in The Washington Post which he jointly authored with Jacqueline Shire in January 2008, wherein he is described as such: “David Albright, a former U.N. weapons inspector, is president of the Institute for Science and International Security.” His erstwhile U.N. credentials appear before his actual job title. Now, this is not uncommon. I do the same thing when describing myself, noting that I was a former U.N. weapons inspector in Iraq from 1991 to 1998. I feel comfortable doing this, because it’s true and because my résumé is relevant to my writing. In his official ISIS biography, Albright details his “U.N. inspector” experience as such: “Albright cooperated actively with the IAEA Action Team from 1992 until 1997, focusing on analyses of Iraqi documents and past procurement activities. In June 1996, he was the first non-governmental inspector of the Iraqi nuclear program. On this inspection mission, Albright questioned members of Iraq’s former uranium enrichment programs about their statements in Iraq’s draft Full, Final, and Complete Declaration.”

Continued . . .

UN: Israel violated truce 7 times in one week


Roi Mandel, YNet, June 26, 2008

UN records 7 incidents of IDF soldiers attempting to drive Palestinian farmers away from border fence by shooting at them. Only one offence marked against Palestinians for firing on Sderot; report does not include most recent rocket fire

Since it went into effect last week, at least eight violations of the new ceasefire agreement with Hamas and the Palestinian factions have been recorded, a UN source told Ynet on Thursday. According to the source, seven violations were committed by the IDF, while the Palestinians are responsible for just one.

However the UN report does not include the Qassam fire launched towards the Negev during the day. "It is important that both sides honor the ceasefire, in order for it to be the first constructive step towards a wider and more extensive peace process between the sides," the source said.

Most of the offences committed by the IDF include shots fired by soldiers at Palestinian farmers attempting to reach their land near the border security fence. According to the UN, on June 20 an IDF patrol shot at Palestinian farmers near the fence east of Rafah. The soldiers fired for ten minutes in order to drive the farmers away, but no injuries were reported.

During the evening of the same day a similar incident was recorded, in which IDF forces shot at Palestinian farmers near the Maghazi refugee camp. Soldiers reportedly fired for five minutes, and no injuries were reported. An hour later soldiers fired towards fisherman near the northern Gaza Strip town of Beit Lahiya in an attempt to drive them away.

Early on June 21 Navy forces opened fire in the same area, and later the same morning forces fired towards Palestinians near the Maghazi refugee camp. No injuries were reported in either case.

70-year old Jamil al-Gahoul was injured from IDF fire two days later, when an army patrol opened fire on a group of Palestinians reportedly gathering wood near Beit Lahiya at 7 am.

Only one Palestinian offence

The first violation committed by the Palestinians was recorded a day later, on June 24, when Islamic Jihad fired three rockets at Sderot from the northern Gaza Strip town of Beit Hanoun.

On Wednesday morning IDF forces opened fire towards Palestinian farmers near the southern Gaza Strip town of Khan Younis. An 82-year old man was seriously injured from the fire, which lasted a few minutes.

Regarding the accusations against Israel the IDF stated that no attacks had been carried out in the Gaza Strip during the past few days, but that some incidents had occurred in which IDF soldiers had carried out operations.

Israel and Hamas have accused each other of violating the ceasefire agreement. Following the rocket fire at Sderot, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said that the fire constitutes a blatant violation of the truce. Defense Minister Ehud Barak decided that the Gaza border crossings would remain closed following the fire, causing Hamas to accuse Israel of infringement of the agreement.

Hanan Greenberg contributed to this report.

Bush is trying to impose a classic colonial status on Iraq

US efforts to force Iraqis to swallow permanent vassal status and give up control of their oil echoes British imperial history

Whatever the Iraq war was about, we were assured, it definitely wasn't about oil. Tony Blair called the idea a "conspiracy theory". It was about democracy and dictatorship, weapons of mass destruction and human rights, anything but oil. Donald Rumsfeld, then US defence secretary, insisted the conflict had "literally nothing to do with oil". When Alan Greenspan, former chairman of the US Federal Reserve, wrote last autumn, "Everyone knows: the Iraq war is largely about oil," he was treated as if he were some senile old gent who'd embarrassingly lost the plot.

That argument is going to be a good deal harder to make from next week, when four of the western world's largest oil corporations are due to sign contracts for the renewed exploitation of Iraq's vast reserves. Initially, these are to be two-year deals to boost production in Iraq's largest oilfields. But not only did the four energy giants - BP, Exxon Mobil, Shell and Total - write their own contracts with the Iraqi government, an unheard-of practice: they have also reportedly secured rights of first refusal on the far more lucrative 30-year production contracts expected once a new US-sponsored oil law is passed, allowing a wholesale western takeover. Big Oil is back with a vengeance.

It's a similar story when it comes to the future of the US occupation itself. The last thing on anyone's mind, we were told when the tanks rolled in, was permanent US control, let alone the recolonisation of Iraq. This was about the Iraqis finally getting a chance to run their own affairs in freedom. But five years on, George Bush and Dick Cheney are putting the screws on their Green Zone government to sign a secret deal for indefinite military occupation, which would effectively reduce Iraq to a long-term vassal state.

Continued . . .

Elections, Capitalism, And Democracy

By Charles Sullivan

26/06/08 "
ICH" -- - Because so many of the people on the political left fear that John McCain will become the next president, they have allowed themselves to see the very moderate democratic candidate, Barach Obama, as a desirable alternative to the decidedly ghoulish McCain, rather than supporting a genuine progressive like Dennis Kucinich, Cynthia McKinney, or Ralph Nader. They thus perceive Obama to be far more progressive than he really is. Such comparisons lead us down a dichotomous pathway that assures a continuous drift to the right.

Each election cycle the people on the left find themselves out-flanked by those on the right by allowing them to frame the debate and to define who we are. So each election we end up supporting a very moderate candidate rather than a truly progressive one. Because all of the mainstream candidates are intensively influenced by corporate lobbyists and the electoral system is owned by capital, democracy has remained as elusive as capturing the ghost of a saint with a piece of duct tape.

According to Ambrose I. Lane Sr., host of Pacifica radio’s “We Ourselves,” John McCain has the third most conservative voting record of anyone in the senate. Running an extremist from the opposite end of the political spectrum forces the democratic candidate further to the right than he or she already is. So when progressives fall into this trap, as they so often do, it is a win-win for the corporate lobbyists pulling the strings behind the curtain. They end up supporting a candidate they think can compete against extremists rather than one who actually represents their values. If you have to become like your opponent in order to defeat them, what can you honesty say has been won?

Continued . . .

The Pentagon's merchants of war

By Nick Turse | TomDipatch.com, June 24, 2008

The top Pentagon contractors, like death and taxes, almost never change. In 2002, the massive arms dealers Lockheed Martin, Boeing and Northrop Grumman ranked one, two and three among Department of Defense (DoD) contractors, taking in US$17 billion, $16.6 billion and $8.7 billion.

Lockheed, Boeing and Northrop Grumman did it again in 2003 ($21.9 billion, $17.3 billion and $11.1 billion); 2004 ($20.7 billion, $17.1 billion and $11.9 billion); 2005 ($19.4 billion, $18.3 billion and $13.5 billion); 2006 ($26.6 billion, $20.3 billion and $16.6 billion); and, not surprisingly, 2007 as well ($27.8 billion $22.5 billion and $14.6 billion).

Other regulars receiving mega-tax-funded payouts in a similarly

clockwork-like manner include defense giants General Dynamics, Raytheon, the British weapons maker BAE Systems and former Halliburton subsidiary KBR, as well as BP, Shell and other power players from the military-petroleum complex.

With the basic Pentagon budget now clocking in at roughly $541 billion per year - before "supplemental" war funding for Iraq, Afghanistan and President George W Bush's "war on terror", as well as national security spending by other agencies, are factored in - even Lockheed's hefty $28 billion take is a small percentage of the massive total. Obviously, significant sums of money are headed to other companies. However, most of them, including some of the largest, are all but unknown even to Pentagon-watchers and antiwar critics with a good grasp of the military industrial complex.

Last year, in a piece headlined "Washington's $8 billion shadow", Vanity Fair published an expose of one of the better-known large stealth contractors, SAIC (Science Applications International Corporation). SAIC, however, is just one of tens of thousands of Pentagon contractors. Many of these firms receive only tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars from the Pentagon every year. Some take home millions, tens of millions or even hundreds of millions of dollars.

Continued . . .

Kashmiri Pandits as victims of Kashmir conflict

A Daniel Came to Judgement

By Badri Raina

Something is rotten in the state of Denmark;
O cursed spite
That ever I was born to set it right.

(Hamlet)

In an act of historic courage (some might say ‘audacity’) the young, bright, and fiercely upright Omar Abdullah has breached the pall of silence in which the Valley has remained suffocated since the exodus of the Pandits in 1990.

In a statement recorded on his blog, (also 1717 hrs IST, PTI, 15 May, 2008), Omar has made the following candid aversions that interrogate Kashmiri Muslims as a whole:

“It is so easy to say that we will lay down our lives to bring Kashmiri

Pandits back to the Valley and I appreciate the sentiment as I am sure

the Kashmiri Pandits reading it will. Pity that the sentiment was missing

when our mosques were being used to drive these people out.. .

None of us was willing to stand up and be counted when it mattered.

None of us grabbed the mikes (microphones) in the mosques and said

‘this is wrong and the Kashmiri Pandits had every right to continue

living in the Valley. . .

Our educated, well-to-do relatives and neighbours were spewing venom

24 hours a day and we were mute spectators, either mute in agreement or

mute in abject fear but mute none the less. . .

And talking about mosques—what a great symbol of mass uprising they

proved to be. While I can’t claim to have lived through it, I have enough

friends who did and they tell me about the early 90’s where attendance

was taken in mosques to force people to pray.”

Questioning the spontaneity of processions taken out in 1990, Omar said people were forced out of their homes to participate in “mass upsurges” against “Indian occupation” and the same enforcement committees went from door to door.

Do recall that not long after, the rath-yatra to Ayodhya was to beat a similar drum of hate-filled, exclusionary cultural politics.

Indeed, this writer was to point out that the yatra was curiously a mirror image of what it sought to confront, as its thrust was to semitise Hinduism (see my “Tenth Avatar of Vishnu, TOI, 17th Feb., 1991) and be like its so-called “other.”

II

Subsequent years and events have shown that the transient attractions of such exclusionary projects notwithstanding (some more seats in the legislatures and in parliament?) Indians overwhelmingly reject such constructions of culture. Immediately after the rath-yatra, the party that led it lost elections in five states, one after the other. And, it is some further irony that in a recent country-wide poll conducted by an electronic channel (ndtv, May 21st, ’08), the projected prime- ministerial candidate of that same party was the country’s fourth choice at a dismal 9.8%, about the same as that still-green Gandhi! Some snub that!

The pity is that a state that had stood rock-like as an example of loving, inter-community existence during the shameful killings of 1946/47, taking on aggression with collective resolve, was to be rendered self-alienated by the events of 1990, not only in social terms but as a spiritual/cultural space.

III

Over the last year or more, increasing numbers of Pandits have been revisiting the Valley chiefly to perform puja and pilgrimage. Media reports on these visits, as well as coverage undertaken daily for a half hour each evening by ETV Urdu Channel have repeatedly shown proof of how heart-rending these renewed contacts between Pandits and Muslims have been.

Pandits have been profoundly moved to discover for themselves how many Hindu shrines are tended by local Muslims, and how close the inter-community inter-face still is among Pandits who have stayed in the Valley and Muslims, the latter most of the time arranging, assisting and conducting Pandit weddings and cremations.

Just the other day, as nine Pandit families returned to their old homes in Verinag to save their houses from being demolished to make way for parking space, these families were astonished at not just the warmth with which their erstwhile Muslim neighbours greeted them, but the bold stand taken by the latter in defence of the right of the Pandits to retain their houses, and the desire expressed by the Muslims to live again next door to them as of old. (What a contrast to Gujarat, you might say.)

The quality and substance of these syncretic cultural reassertions are precisely the sort that this writer has consistently experienced in my visits to the valley (see my “Valley of Love,” Frontline, Aug.1, 2003).

IV

Yet, something has been missing—a major expression of culpability and complicity, coerced or not, in the events of 1990. Kashmir has been waiting for its Hamlet, a whistle-blower who would speak the word of cathartic shame, letting the genie out that would begin to scatter the dark cobwebs of guilt and suppression. Omar Abdullah has come forward as that angel that blows the conch of confession and return.

In saying what he has said, Omar recalls the imperishable truth that cruelties and inhumane distortions notwithstanding, the demons of the culture of hate-filled exclusion remain alien to the heart of Kashmiris. And he also recalls a legacy that in modern times was enunciated by that towering human being, his grand father, Sheikh Mohammed Abdullah.

Recall that in late 1947 when Sardar Patel invoked the Nawabs of Junagarh and Hyderabad to follow the will of the people in the matter of accession, the Sheikh, agreeing with that view, posed himself the question: what should Kashmir do?

And, weeks before the aggression from across the line, or the accession and the coming of the Indian army, answered that question in a public speech on October 4, 1947; and this is what he said:

“We shall not believe . . .the two-nation theory which has spread so much

Poison. Kashmir showed the light at that juncture. When brother kills

brother in the whole of Hindustan, Kashmir raised its voice of Hindu-

Muslim unity. I can assure the Hindu and Sikh minorities that as long as

I am alive their life and honour will be quite safe.”(see M.J. Akbar,

Kashmir: Behind the Vale, p.xiv)

And, speaking to the U.N. General Assembly on Feb. 5, 1948, this is what the Sheikh said:

“I and my organization never believed in the formula that Muslims and

Hindus form separate nations. We do not believe in the two-nation

theory, nor in communal hatred or communalism itself. We believed that

religion has no place in politics. Therefore when we launched our ‘Quit

Kashmir’ movement it was not only Muslims who suffered but our Hindu

and Sikh comrades as well.”(Association of Communal Harmony in

Asia—ACHA, Archive of Kashmir Resources).

Thus, as Hamlet was moved by the noble example of his deceived father-king, Omar speaks today the noble legacy of the Sheikh yet again. And not a day too soon.

V

The question might be asked as to what are the resources from whence the unique Kashmiri Weltanschauung of love and humanism derives. This history is by now made familiar by many scholars. Let me only leave you with the following citations that bear on the theme from the ancient to the modern:

“Kashmir may be conquered by the force of spiritual merit but never

by the force of soldiers” (Kalhana)


“Shiv chuy thali thali rozan; Shiv lives everywhere; do not

Mo zan Hindu ta Musalman. divide Hindu from Muslim. . .

Truk ay chuk pan panun prazanav,

Soy chay sahibas zaniy zan.” (Lal Ded)


“Do not go to the Sheikh or priest or mullah; do not feed the cattle on

poisonous leaves. Do not shut yourselves up in mosques or forests.

Enter your own body, control your breath, and commune with

Gods” (Sheikh Noor-u-din, alias Nund rishi).


“The most respectable class in this country is that of the Rishis who,

notwithstanding their need of freedom from the bonds of tradition and

custom, are true worshippers of God. They do not loosen the tongue

of calumny against those not of their faith. . . (Abul Fazl, Ain-e-Akbari)


“Mohammed…radiates light all around;

Pujari lost his wits,

While offering flowers,

Iswara showered rain,

Come let us blow the sankh

Around Sankara. . . (Ahad Zargar)

(see Riyaz Punjabi, Kashmiriyat: Mystique of an Ethnicity” Miraas, Vol.1, No.1, ed., Pankaj Bhan at the Kasheer Foundation, Gulmohar Park, ND., for a more extensive discussion of the overlap between Hindu and Muslim mysticism in the Valley from the earliest times to the twentieth century.)

VI

Yet, the problem remains with us. Subsequent to the schism of 1990, many Pandits look for a cultural tradition exclusive to them, and in so doing, revisit the earliest Sharda literatures, beginning with the Nilamat Purana, etc., as they seek to reinvent an exclusively Hindu-aboriginal identity. Conversely, some Sunni Muslim groups propagate that syncretism was always a false construction, and that Muslims are enjoined, as in Arab countries, to follow the pristine Salafi/Wahabi path which forbids the notions of a personal discovery of godhead, the ethic of eros, music, idol-worship, ecstatic ritual, commingling with non-believers, and so on.

It is another matter that some eighty percent of Muslims actually live outside the Arab world—some seventy percent in Asia—and that in each national culture and history religions have always acquired features all their own.

Be that as it may, there is evidence that the people of Kashmir continue to internalize syncretism in ways that no theoretical formulations of an imposed nature are about to dislodge. Omar Abdullah’s call to confession and reconciliation indeed would have been either unthinkable or already severely castigated had that not been so.

A striking evidence of that truth is, for example, to be found in the pages of the book, Eighty Three Days: The Story of a Frozen River, by Dr. S.N.Dhar, a highly reputed Pandit physician.

Dr. Dhar was picked up by militants early in 1992, constantly moved from location to location but held captive for eighty three days. The book recounts what he suffered and what he learnt: among other things, he was to conclude: “in spite of the atmosphere of mistrust and suspicion, I found most of the young gunmen innocent and caring, some of whom held the Kashmiri Pandits in high esteem.”

And upon his release and return home: “within no time my neighbours, then more people and then even more people arrived, greeting me with showers of almonds and shireen. . .I was overwhelmed by this spontaneous expression of love and concern. . . . Something had happened, somehow an ordinary Kashmiri’s emotions of love hitherto suppressed, burst like a volcano, transforming into touching and dramatic scenes, for which a Kashmiri is known anyway. The more I saw of this, the more I resolved to be where I belonged---losing my freedom once again---this time to the chains of love” (pp.viii and 180).

An old college senior and cricketing friend, Dr. Dhar invited me to his home in Rajya Bagh in 2004 along with other Kashmiri friends of all denominations. There I had further proof that what we had lost was both recoverable and poignantly desirable of recovery.

Kashmiri Pandits who say they want to go back but to a sequestered “homeland” must introspect just as much as Omar Abdullah and Dr. Dhar do in what I have cited. Apart from taking in with open minds the experiences of those others, besides Dr. Dhar, who never left the valley and whose lives remain watched over by their fellow Muslim Kashmiris.

What, then, must now be discussed among all groups is how are ways to be found to extend the Omar initiative into a more embracing collective endeavour directed at exorcising the ghosts of the unnatural events of 1990. Other states and nations have done so with inspiring successes, although without chasing the faultless perfections of utopia.

For it is that sort of effort which alone can guarantee the safe and willing return of Pandits to their homeland, the reinstallation of ways of living that have had to yield to unlovely distortions, and to once again set an example to the nation and the world of how desirable macro-identities can be constructed from unstable, violent and sectarian ones.

It is also the only sure way in which the demons of communalism in the heartland of India and Pakistan can be shamed and defeated.
______________________________________________________________