by Ralph Nader, Counterpunch, Dec 18, 2023

Image by Kim Silverstein. Courtesy JVP.
In the midst of Netanyahu’s annihilation of innocent Palestinian
civilians in Gaza, many of them children, women and the elderly, there
is a rising urgency from many Israeli and domestic Jewish groups for an
immediate ceasefire and greatly increasing the flow of humanitarian aid.
In the U.S. Jewish Voice for Peace and If Not Now have vigorously
engaged in public non-violent civil disobedience – an American tradition
– to challenge the inhumane unconditional co-belligerency by Congress
and Joe Biden of the present extremist regime’s genocidal destruction of
Palestinians. Many U.S. Jewish Americans are standing tall either
individually or in groups to exclaim “not in our name” to the
U.S.-funded civilian slaughter in Gaza.
A most remarkable, little-noticed open letter to President Joe Biden
appeared in December 13, 2023, New York Times,paid for by the legendary
Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem and signed by 16 other
Israeli peace, human rights, veterans and religious associations. (See
the letter here).
Titled “The Humanitarian Catastrophe in the Gaza Strip,” the letter
condemns the Hamas “horrific and criminal attack on Israeli civilians”
and demands the release of the Israelis in Gaza. What follows are
excerpts from their message to the White House:
“Since the war began, Israel’s policy has driven the humanitarian
crisis in Gaza to the point of catastrophe – not only as an inevitable
outcome of war. As part of this policy, soon after the fighting began,
Israel stopped selling Gaza electricity and water, closed its crossings
and blocked all entry of food, water, fuel and medicine.”
Citing international law and committed war crimes, the signers continue:
“UN agencies and humanitarian organizations report that the situation
in Gaza is catastrophic and they have almost no way left to help the
population. The few truckloads that are allowed in – a drop in the
ocean, according to the reports – cannot be distributed due to the
ongoing bombardments, the destruction of infrastructure and restrictions
imposed by Israel. This leaves more than two million people hungry and
thirsty, without access to proper medical care, and with infectious
diseases spreading due to unhygienic overcrowding and lack of water.
This inconceivable reality grows worse by the day.”
“You [Biden] have the power to influence our government to change its
policy and allow humanitarian aid into Gaza, in accordance with
Israel’s legal obligations ….”
“We are in the final throes of an emergency. Many deaths can still be prevented. Israel must change its policy now.”
The estimated death toll in Gaza at “more than 18,000” is a gross
undercount. Well over ten times more children in Gaza have been killed
in nine weeks than the number of children lost in the Russian war on
Ukraine over nearly 22 months. In addition to the unprecedented intense
bombing, large numbers of Palestinian infants, children, women, the
infirmed, and disabled are homeless, facing the elements, dying by the
minute from the homicidal conditions described by these Israeli human
rights groups, journalists, and recorded by U.S. drones above Gaza.
Being reduced to rubble, Gaza has no fire trucks or water to put out
spreading fires. The Israeli military has destroyed or rendered the vast
majority of hospitals and health clinics inoperative. UN relief
agencies are shelled and have seen over 130 of their staff slain.
The Israeli war machine has also taken the lives of over 60
Palestinian journalists (many with their families), including three
Israeli reporters. Consistent with its long-time exclusion of outside
journalists, the Israeli government doesn’t want the world to see and
hear from unembedded, mainstream Israeli or foreign journalists.
Day after deadly day, President Biden, Secretary of State Blinken and
Secretary of Defense Austin used words to urge minimizing Palestinian
casualties while they deploy deeds of massive shipments of bombs,
missiles and UN vetoes. Small wonder our government officials are having
little restraining influence. The Israeli Air Force even bombs and
contaminates the small agricultural areas destroying olive groves and
fields growing grain, vegetable and fruit crops. It is even against
Israeli law for Palestinians to collect rainwater which is decreed to be
the property of the state.
Pope Francis, long a protector of Jewish rights when he was a cleric
in Argentina, called Israeli President Isaac Herzog to express his deep
concern about the plight of the Palestinians, saying that “it is
forbidden to respond to terror with terror.” The Vatican reported that
the Holy Father is in constant touch with the “Christian Church” in Gaza
and the West Bank. For decades, Christians in the West Bank have been
harassed, discriminated against and encroached upon (e.g., Bethlehem)
with little media coverage, except for the courageous Israeli newspaper
Haaretz.
Oblivious to world opinion, including that of our allies, Biden and
the Democrats are pushing for another $14.3 billion in U.S. taxpayer
monies to further annihilate the defenseless, now homeless, human beings
in Gaza, screaming in pain and fear, sick, starving and dying, unable
to bury their kin. Rotting corpses are piling up, and being eaten by
stray dogs.
Meanwhile, people in the U.S. who speak out for stopping this
brutality are charged with being “antisemitic” – a grotesque cheapening
and misuse of a word that was used to describe the savage Russian
pogroms and Nazi horrors of extermination. Silencing peaceful criticism
with this slander is a conscious tactic. Note the statement by Shulamit
Aloni, a former Minister of Education and winner of the Israel Prize:
“It’s a trick. We always use it. When from Europe, somebody
criticizes Israel, we bring up the Holocaust. When, in the United
States, people are critical of Israel, then they are anti-Semitic.”
It works all too often. Americans are smeared, being suspended or
losing their jobs, their careers, and their customers because they
oppose the carnage in Gaza. It is a sign of the partisan censorship that
incurring such penalties is not experienced by Americans exclaiming
their full support for this genocidal obliteration of Gaza – a multiple
war crime pointed out by both Jewish and non-Jewish international law
scholars here and abroad.
The least that humane citizens can do is to tell their members of
Congress to demand a permanent ceasefire, the release of the Israeli
hostages and the large number of Palestinian prisoners (children, women
and men) in Israeli jails without charges or due process, and serious
movement toward a two-state solution.
The switchboard in Congress is 202-224-3121.
Ralph Nader is a consumer advocate, lawyer and author of Only the Super-Rich Can Save Us!