I was born in Poonch (Kashmir) and now I live in Norway. I oppose war and violence and am a firm believer in the peaceful co-existence of all nations and peoples. In my academic work I have tried to espouse the cause of the weak and the oppressed in a world dominated by power politics, misleading propaganda and violations of basic human rights. I also believe that all conscious members of society have a moral duty to stand for and further the cause of peace and human rights throughout the world.
The Biden administration continues to act contrary to logic and
humane values in response to Israel’s war policies. Despite overwhelming
evidence of Israel’s war crimes and acts that constitute genocide, the
administration plies the right-wing Israeli government with more
weapons. The latest arms package
being prepared by the administration will reportedly be the largest
since the Oct. 7 Hamas attack. Valued at around $18 billion, it will
include 50 F-15 fighter jets and precision-guided munitions kits as well
as more 2000- and 500-pound bombs.
Many critics, including some within the administration itself, have
pointed with alarm to the obvious contradiction in US policy between
supporting negotiations on a cease-fire and hostage release on one hand,
and continuing to ship non-defensive weapons to Israel on the other.
The contradiction applies not just to the immediate situation in Israel
but also to overall US policy on the abuse of military aid—NSM 20—which
specifies that arms recipients must adhere to international and American
law. Israel, while giving assurances about its use of US weapons, has
violated US policy guidelines in numerous ways—for instance, bombing
hospitals and other civilian targets with US bombs, and using
US-supplied white phosphorus munitions in densely populated areas of
Gaza.
Such violations make the US complicit in Israel’s war crimes and genocide, which Oxfam and Human Rights Watch documented in a joint letter
submitted to the administration March 13. Just recently, the UN Special
Rapporteur on Palestinian rights condemned Israel’s “genocide” in Gaza
and proposed an arms embargo on Israel. If the Biden administration
wants to be taken seriously when it demands Israel’s restraint in its
Gaza operations, calls for a “sustainable” cease-fire, and insists on
Israel’s removal of obstacles to the delivery of humanitarian aid, it
must stop delivery of non-defensive weapons to Israel. Otherwise, such
calls lack credibility, undercut any leverage the US might have on
Israeli policy, and spotlight the US role in prolonging the war and
contributing to the horrific humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
Mel Gurtov is Professor Emeritus of Political Science at Portland State University, Editor-in-Chief of Asian Perspective, an international affairs quarterly and blogs at In the Human Interest.
Joe Biden has long had a problem with PEACE – as in “ceasefires,”
“serious peace negotiations,” and conditioning the transfer or sale of
major weapons systems as required by five U.S. criminal statutes. From
one side of his mouth, Biden urges futilely Israeli compliance with
international law while on the other side he supports the daily shipment
of weapons of mass destruction to the Israeli government. These weapons
are being used in the genocidal killing of Palestinians in Gaza.
A majority in Congress is even more hawkish and lets Biden do
whatever he wants in making war abroad. The cornerstone of our
Constitution – the separation of powers – has been demolished in area
after area. (See, our open letter of November 28, 2023, to the members
of the U.S. Congress).
By contrast, American public opinion has turned against U.S. arms
shipments to Israel and the annihilation of Palestinian civilians from
infants to the elderly. Whole extended families are being wiped out by
American-made bombs and missiles. The homeless survivors are injured,
starving and suffering from untold illnesses.
The Israeli state terror is producing a Palestinian Holocaust.
Netanyahu’s violent anti-semitism against the Arabs of Palestine is out
of control. Many courageous Israeli human rights groups protest, to no
avail, (See, the December 13, 2023, open letter to Biden that appeared
in the New York Times) as Netanyahu and his extremist coalition reveal
their long-time objective of driving millions of Palestinians out of
what is left of their Palestine.
As for the Hamas raid on October 7th, and the total collapse of the
highly touted Israeli border security, a World War II Holocaust survivor
told the New York Times, “It should never have happened…” Yet,
Netanyahu has blocked an official investigation of this unexplained
multi-tiered technological and human intelligence debacle.
Meanwhile, public dissatisfaction with the dictatorial
decision-making by the White House and the absence of Congressional
action is growing rapidly. More and more labor unions are now opposing
Biden’s bombings, Jewish Americans working with Jewish Voice for Peace
and If Not Now are brilliantly organizing demonstrations. Veterans for
Peace’s 27 chapters around the country are in the streets peacefully
demanding a ceasefire, cessation of weapons shipments and major
increases in humanitarian aid. They are mostly ignored by the corporate
media, NPR and PBS.
Religious groups are beseechingly calling for peace. This week in the
latest public letter, 140 Global Christian Leaders, organized by
Churches for Middle East Peace (CMEP) called on President Biden “…to
have the moral courage to end U.S. complicity in the ongoing violence
and, instead, do everything in [his] power to…” stop the “death and
destruction” in Palestine.
The CMEP receives little or no coverage by the mainstream media even though this organization represents millions of people.
But then look who is not taking a pro-peace stand, staying silent or
actively backing the Israeli war machine. The American Legion and the
Veterans of Foreign Wars are on the sidelines. The AFL-CIO Labor
Federation finally came out tepidly for a ceasefire but has exerted very
little of its muscle on Capitol Hill.
AIPAC, the “pro-Israeli government can do no wrong lobby” has been
cultivating relationships with these U.S. organizations and others like
them for decades.
The worst abdications have come from the legal profession in the form
of State Bar Associations and the American Bar Association (ABA) – the
largest organization of lawyers in the world. These lawyers are all
“officers of the court” instructed to stand for the rule of law. Except
for a brief time in 2005-2006
(https://nader.org/2013/04/19/aba-white-papers/ ) the ABA has idled
while Presidents regularly have violated our Constitution and all kinds
of laws – domestic and international – with impunity, facilitated by a
supine Congress.
Bruce Fein and I have asked 50 State Bar Associations to be first
responders in challenging the ongoing breakdown of the rule of law due
to their professional duties and knowledge. None have responded.
As for the healthcare professionals watching Israel raining death and
destruction directly on Gaza’s hospitals and health clinics, inundated
with desperate patients, their endangered physicians and assistants
without the means to devote their care, the response is overwhelmingly
silent. The American Public Health Association and the American Medical
Student Association are among the few to have condemned Israel’s
atrocities.
Yet, the desperate pleas by their wounded professional colleagues
have failed to register with the likes of the American Medical
Association, the American College of Surgeons, the American Academy of
Family Physicians, the American Association for the Surgery of Trauma
and many others. (See the letter of March 1, 2024, which has gone
unanswered).
What can turn our country around? An organized citizenry of less than
one percent of the voters in Congressional Districts, giving voice to
the voiceless majority, can free Congress from its captivity imposed by
the forces of greed, power and violent Empire, draining resources from
our dire domestic needs.
As I wrote in the Capitol Hill Citizen (February/March 2024 issue),
Congress has become a weapon of mass destruction with multiple warheads.
Only the people can recover their sovereign power, under the
Constitution, now delegated to a Congress that sells out to the highest
corporatist bidders.
On the Israeli slaughter of Gaza’s people, a small but growing number
of Democrats in Congress are standing tall. They need your active
backing to expand their numbers. (See, Ceasefire Tracker:
https://workingfamilies.org/ceasefire-tracker/).
As for the cruel, vicious, genocidal, maniacal Republicans, they
remain disgraced in their full-throttled support for Netanyahu, who is
fighting for his job, trying to escape Israeli prosecutors and is hugely
unpopular in Israel.
The GOP position was expressed by Arkansas Senator Tom Cotton – a
lawyer no less – who said last October, for posterity’s eternal
damnation: “As far as I’m concerned, Israel can bounce the rubble in
Gaza.” This is exactly what the massacring Israeli juggernauts have done
with the weapons, taxpayers’ money and diplomatic cover enabled by
corrupt outlaws like Tom Cotton.
The Biden administration has approved billions of dollars worth of bombs and fighter jets
for Israel to support the slaughter and starvation of Palestinians in
Gaza despite claims from US officials that they’re concerned about the
massive civilian casualty rate.
US officials told The Washington Post that the
administration approved the transfer of 500 MK82 500-pound bombs and
more than 1,800 MK84 2,000-pound bombs, which Israel has used to kill
scores of civilians by dropping them on Gaza’s densely populated cities.
The administration also approved the transfer of 25 F-35 fighter jets
to Israel, a deal worth $2.5 billion that’s likely being paid for by US
military aid to Israel. US officials said both transfers had been
approved by Congress years ago and not fulfilled, so lawmakers were not
notified about the final approval.
A White House official confirmed to the Post that US military aid to Israel is still unconditional. “Conditioning aid has not been our policy,” the official said.
News of the weapons transfers came after Israeli Defense Minister
Yoav Gallant visited Washington to ensure continued US support for
Israel’s brutal campaign. While President Biden and Israeli Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu appear to be at odds in public, behind the
scenes, US support for Israel continues unabated.
Gaza’s Health Ministry said on Sunday that 32,782 Palestinians
have been killed and 75,298 have been wounded since October 7. The
total of dead includes over 13,000 children. The numbers from Gaza’s
Health Ministry are considered low estimates since they don’t take into
account the thousands who are missing and presumed dead under the
rubble.
Francesca Albanese on January 03, 2024 in Ariano Irpino, Italy. [Ivan Romano/Getty Images]
A United Nations expert who published a report saying there were
reasonable grounds to believe Israel has committed genocide in Gaza
during its military campaign in Gaza said today that she had received
threats throughout her mandate, Reuters reports.
Francesca Albanese, the Special Rapporteur on the human rights situation in the West Bank and Gaza, presented a report entitled “Anatomy of a Genocide” to the UN Human Rights Council yesterday, which Israel said it “utterly rejects”.
Asked whether her work on the report had caused her to receive
threats, Albanese said: “Yes, I do receive threats. Nothing that so far I
considered needing extra precautions. Pressure? Yes, and it doesn’t
change either my commitment or the results of my work.”
Albanese, who has held the position since 2022, did not elaborate on
the nature of the threats, nor did she say who had issued them.
“It’s been a difficult time,” she said. “I’ve always been attacked since the very beginning of my mandate.”
Israel has harangued Albanese, saying she was “delegitimising the
very creation and existence of the State of Israel.” Albanese denied the
accusation.
Albanese said one of her key findings was that Israel’s executive and
military leadership and soldiers have intentionally “subverted their
protection functions in an attempt to legitimise genocidal violence
against the Palestinian people.”
“The only reasonable inference that can be drawn from the unveiling
of this policy is an Israeli state policy of genocidal violence toward
the Palestinian people in Gaza,” she said.
Israel’s diplomatic mission in Geneva said the use of the word
genocide was “outrageous” and said the war was against Hamas and not
Palestinian civilians. In spite of its claims, over 70 per cent of the
victims of Israel’s bombing campaign have been women and children, with
civilians rounded up, stripped and disappeared from across the Strip.
Over the past week there have been numerous reports of rape of Palestinian women by Israeli occupation soldiers, many in front of their husbands and brothers.
Israel stands accused of genocide at the ICJ, which in January issued an interim ruling
that ordered Tel Aviv to stop genocidal acts and take measures to
guarantee that humanitarian assistance is provided to civilians in Gaza.
Since the verdict in January, Israel has tightened its siege on
northern Gaza and reduced the entry of aid, causing a man-made famine.
As the Israeli military is poised to escalate its genocide in Gaza
with a long-planned offensive in the southern city of Rafah, Defence
Minister Yoav Gallant has left for talks in Washington with top US
officials. Last Friday, Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made
clear that the barbaric operation into the city crammed with 1.5 million
Palestinian refugees will proceed.
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken with Israeli Defence Minister Yoav Gallant, Nov. 30, 2023. [AP Photo/Saul Loeb]
Amid ongoing international outrage and protests against the Israeli
genocide, the Biden administration has expressed concerns about the
Rafah offensive. US Secretary of State Antony Blinken met with Netanyahu
in Israel last Friday and warned that the operation “risks further
isolating Israel around the world and jeopardising its long-term
security.” Vice President Kamila Harris told ABC’s “This Week” on Sunday
that any military operation into Rafah “would be a huge mistake” and
dropped a hint that there would be “consequences” for Israel.
These meaningless expressions of concern are simply window dressing
for behind-the-scenes talks that will focus on how, not if, the Israeli
war in Gaza is going to reach a bloody climax in Rafah. The Biden
administration, which regards the conflict as part of a wider war in the
Middle East targeting Iran, has backed Israel to the hilt—politically,
financially and militarily with the supply of huge quantities of arms.
Gallant’s comments prior to his departure only underscored the
character of the upcoming talks with Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin,
Secretary of State Blinken and national security adviser Jake Sullivan.
“During my visit, I will focus on preserving Israel’s qualitative
military edge and on ways to achieve our common goals: victory over
Hamas and returning the hostages home,” he said in a statement issued by
his office.
As well as focussing on Israel’s “ability to obtain platforms and
munitions,” Gallant signalled that he and US top officials would discuss
the opening of a new military front in southern Lebanon against
Iranian-backed Hezbollah. The conflict has been underway and escalating
since the Israeli war in Gaza began, involving Israeli strikes deep
inside Lebanon as well as in the border area with Israel. Tens of
thousands have been displaced.
The top figures in the Zionist regime in Israel have been pressing
for a military offensive against Hezbollah to drive its militia forces
back from the border. “We will also discuss the need to return Israel’s
northern communities to their homes, whether this is achieved via
military action or via agreement,” Gallant said. Given that Israel knows
that its demands for Hezbollah to pull back some 30 kilometres from the
border are completely unacceptable, what will be discussed involves a
dramatic escalation of the conflict into Lebanon.
The desperate situation for the Palestinians in Gaza only intensified
on Sunday as the Israeli military stepped up its onslaught and Israeli
authorities told the UN that the UN refugee agency, UNRWA, would no
longer be allowed to send food convoys into northern Gaza. “As of today,
UNRWA, the main lifeline for Palestine refugees, is denied from
providing lifesaving assistance to northern
Gaza,” UNRWA Commissioner-General Philippe Lazzarini wrote in a post on
Twitter/X.
Lazzarini demanded that the restrictions be lifted, declaring: “This
is outrageous & makes it intentional to obstruct lifesaving
assistance during a man-made famine… By preventing UNRWA to fulfill its
mandate in Gaza, the clock will tick faster towards famine & many
more will die of hunger, dehydration + lack of shelter. This cannot
happen, it would only stain our collective humanity.”
The cynicism of the Biden administration’s expressions of concern for
the plight of Palestinian refugees was underscored by its lack of
funding for the UNRWA. The newly passed US foreign aid spending bills
puts severe limits on funding for the UN agency until at least March
2025. Lazzarini emphasised the urgency for assistance declaring that
humanitarian agencies were in a race against time to avoid famine. Any
gap in funding would undermine access to food, shelter, primary health
care and education at an extremely difficult time.
After visiting Egypt’s border with Gaza at the Rafah crossing on
Saturday, UN Secretary General António Guterres reiterated his call for a
ceasefire. “Looking at Gaza, it almost appears that the four horsemen
of war, famine, conquest and death are galloping across it,” he said,
adding that nothing justifies the collective punishment of Palestinians.
Having been at the border where some 7,000 aid trucks are waiting for
Israeli approval to enter Gaza, Guterres declared that the starvation
being inflicted on Palestinians was a “moral outrage”. He called on
Israel to remove the “obstacles and chokepoints to relief,” saying:
“Palestinians in Gaza desperately need what has been promised: a flood
of aid… not trickles, not drops.”
Even before Gallant’s talks in Washington begin, the Israeli military
is intensifying its assault in southern Gaza. The Israeli military
carried out around 40 strikes in the al-Amal neighbourhood in Khan
Younis to the north of Rafah while its troops were “encircling the area
and continuing to eliminate” alleged Hamas militants. It also sent tanks
into the al-Qarara area in northern Khan Younis, backed by airstrikes.
The Palestine Red Crescent Society reported on Sunday that Israeli
forces were “besieging” al-Amal Hospital in Khan Younis. It stated that
the military was using bulldozers and smoke bombs around the hospital
and demanding that everyone inside evacuate. A PRCS emergency services
volunteer in the facility reported “intense and continuous shelling”, as
well as “continuous gunfire.” He was later killed by Israeli gunfire.
In Gaza City, the Israeli siege of the al-Shifa Hospital continued on
Sunday despite calls by Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the director
general of the World Health Organization, on Thursday to halt the
attacks that have cut off access to the facility. “We repeat once again:
hospitals are not battlegrounds. They must be protected in line with
international humanitarian law.” The Israeli military declared that it
has detained 480 “suspects” for interrogation including health workers.
According to the Gaza Health Ministry, at least 32,226 people have
been killed and 74,518 injured in Gaza since the war began. That figure
will only increase dramatically as Israeli forces mount their offensive
into Rafah.
The “temporary pier” being built on the Mediterranean coast of Gaza
is not there to alleviate the famine, but to herd Palestinians onto
ships and into permanent exile.
Piers allow things to come in. They allow things to go out. And
Israel, which has no intention of halting its murderous siege of Gaza,
including its policy of enforced starvation, appears to have found a
solution to its problem of where to expel the 2.3 million Palestinians.
If the Arab world will not take them, as Secretary of State Antony
Blinken proposed during his first round of visits after Oct. 7, the
Palestinians will be cast adrift on ships. It worked in Beirut in 1982
when some eight and a half thousand Palestine Liberation Organization
members were sent
by sea to Tunisia and another two and a half thousand ended up in other
Arab states. Israel expects that the same forced deportation by sea
will work in Gaza.
Israel, for this reason, supports the “temporary pier” the Biden administration is building, to ostensibly deliver food and aid to Gaza – food and aid whose “distribution” will be overseen by the Israeli military.
“You need drivers that don’t exist, trucks that don’t exist feeding
into a distribution system that doesn’t exist,” Jeremy Konyndyk, a
former senior aid official in the Biden administration, and now
president of the Refugees International aid advocacy group told The Guardian.
This “maritime corridor” is Israel’s Trojan Horse, a subterfuge to
expel Palestinians. The small shipments of seaborne aid, like the food
packets that have been air dropped, will not alleviate the looming
famine. They are not meant to.
Five Palestinians were killed
and several others injured when a parachute carrying aid failed and
crashed onto a crowd of people near Gaza City’s Shati refugee camp.
“Dropping aid in this way is flashy propaganda rather than a
humanitarian service,” the media office of the local government in Gaza said.
“We previously warned it poses a threat to the lives of citizens in the
Gaza Strip, and this is what happened today when the parcels fell on
the citizens’ heads.”
If the U.S. or Israel were serious about alleviating the humanitarian crisis, the thousands of trucks with food and aid currently at the southern border of Gaza would be allowed to enter any of its multiple
crossings. They are not. The “temporary pier,” like the air drops, is
ghoulish theater, a way to mask Washington’s complicity in the
genocide.
Israeli media reported
the building of the pier was due to pressure by the United Arab
Emirates, which threatened Israel with ending a land corridor trade
route it administers in collusion with Saudi Arabia and Jordan, to bypass Yemen’s naval blockade.
The Jerusalem Post reported it was Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu who proposed the construction of the “temporary pier” to the Biden administration.
Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, who has called
Palestinians “human animals” and advocated a total siege of Gaza,
including cutting off electricity, food, water and fuel, lauded the
plan, saying “it is designed to bring aid directly to the residents and thus continue the collapse of Hamas’s rule in Gaza.”
“Why would Israel, the engineer of the Gaza famine, endorse the idea
of establishing a maritime corridor for aid to address a crisis it
initiated and is now worsening?” writes
Tamara Nassar in an article titled “What’s the Real Purpose of Biden’s
Gaza Port?” in The Electronic Intifada. “This might appear paradoxical
if one were to assume that the primary aim of the maritime corridor is
to deliver aid.”
When Israel offers a gift to the Palestinians you can be sure it is a poison apple. That Israel got the Biden administration to construct
the pier is one more example of the inverted relationship between
Washington and Jerusalem, where the Israel lobby has bought off elected
officials in the two ruling parties.
Oxfam in a March 15 report accuses
Israel of actively hindering aid operations in Gaza in defiance of the
orders by the International Court of Justice. It notes that 1.7 million
Palestinians, some 75 percent of the Gaza population, are facing famine
and two-thirds of the hospitals and over 80 percent of all health
clinics in Gaza are no longer operable. The majority of people, the
report reads, “have no access to clean drinking water” and “sanitation
services are not functioning.”
The report reads:
The conditions we have observed in Gaza are beyond catastrophic, and
we have not only seen failure by Israeli authorities to meet their
responsibility to facilitate and support international aid efforts, but
in fact seen active steps being taken to hinder and undermine such aid
efforts. Israel’s control of Gaza continues to be characterized by
deliberate restrictive actions that have led to a severe and systemic
dysfunctionality in the delivery of aid. Humanitarian organizations
operational in Gaza are reporting a worsening situation since the
International Court of Justice imposed provisional measures in light of
the plausible risk of genocide, with intensified Israeli barriers,
restrictions and attacks against humanitarian personnel. Israel has
maintained a ‘convenient illusion of a response’ in Gaza to serve its
claim that it is allowing aid in and conducting the war in line with
international laws.
Oxfam says Israel employs “a dysfunctional and undersized inspection
system that keeps aid snarled up, subjected to onerous, repetitive and
unpredictable bureaucratic procedures that are contributing to trucks
being stranded in giant queues for 20 days on average.” Israel, Oxfam explains,
rejects “items of aid as having ‘dual (military) use,’ banning vital
fuel and generators entirely along with other items essential for a
meaningful humanitarian response such as protective gear and
communications kit.” Rejected aid, “must go through a complex
‘pre-approval’ system or end up being held in limbo at the Al Arish
warehouse in Egypt.” Israel has also “cracked down on humanitarian
missions, largely sealing off northern Gaza, and restricting
international humanitarian workers’ access not only into Gaza, but
Israel and the West Bank including East Jerusalem too.”
Israel has allowed 15,413 trucks into Gaza during the past 157 days
of war. Oxfam estimates that the population of Gaza needs five times
that number. Israel allowed 2,874 trucks in February, a 44 percent
reduction from the previous month. Before Oct. 7, 500 aid trucks entered Gaza daily.
Israeli soldiers have also killed scores of Palestinians attempting to receive aid from trucks in more than two dozenincidents. These attacks include
the killing of at least 21 Palestinians, and the wounding of 150, on
March 14, when Israeli forces fired on thousands of people in Gaza City.
The same area had been targeted by Israeli soldiers hours earlier.
“Israel’s assault has caught Gaza’s own aid workers and international
agencies’ partners inside a ‘practically uninhabitable’ environment of
mass displacement and deprivation, where 75 percent of solid waste is
now being dumped in random sites, 97 percent of groundwater made unfit
for human use, and the Israeli state using starvation as a weapon of
war,” Oxfam says.
There is no place in Gaza, Oxfam notes, that is safe “amid the
forcible and often multiple displacements of almost the entire
population, which makes the principled distribution of aid unviable,
including agencies’ ability to help repair vital public services at
scale.”
Oxfam blasts Israel for its “disproportionate” and “indiscriminate”
attacks on “civilian and humanitarian assets” as well as “solar, water,
power and sanitation plants, UN premises, hospitals, roads, and aid
convoys and warehouses, even when these assets are supposedly
‘deconflicted’ after their coordinates have been shared for protection.”
The health ministry in Gaza said Monday that at least 31,726 people
have been killed since the Israeli assault began five months ago. The
death toll includes at least 81 deaths in the previous 24 hours, a
ministry statement said, adding that 73,792 people have been wounded in
Gaza since Oct. 7. Thousands more are missing, many buried under the
rubble.
None of these Israeli tactics will be altered with the building of a
“temporary pier.” In fact, given the pending ground assault on Rafah,
where 1.2 million displaced Palestinians are crowded in tent cities or
camped out in the open air, Israel’s tactics will only get worse.
Israel, by design, is creating a humanitarian crisis of such
catastrophic proportions, with thousands of Palestinians killed by
bombs, shells, missiles, bullets, starvation and infectious diseases,
that the only option will be death or deportation. The pier is where the
last act in this gruesome genocidal campaign will be played out as
Palestinians are herded by Israeli soldiers onto ships.
How appropriate that the Biden administration, without whom this genocide could not be carried out, will facilitate it.
In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is
distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest
in receiving the included information for research and educational
purposes. Information Clearing House has no affiliation whatsoever with
the originator of this article nor is Information ClearingHouse endorsed
or sponsored by the originator.)
Views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Information Clearing House.